Injecting Those Dependencies 171

Posted by Brett Schuchert Mon, 22 Mar 2010 21:00:00 GMT

Last week I was teaching a class with a good group of C++ developers in Chicago. They were up on C++, current standardization efforts, virtual machines, performance analysis and tuning. At one point I mentioned a metric for virtual method dispatch on the JVM and one of the students used my numbers to work backwards to determine the number of instructions on different processors.

I was teaching our Working Effectively with Legacy Code class. Michael Feathers usually teaches this class, but he was busy (probably working with legacy code somewhere, which, ironically, is why he wrote the book – to solve the problem once and for all and to stop working with legacy code).

In an early project we have some problem code (the class was in Java, but we discussed C++ quite a bit):
    public void addEvent(Event event) {
        event.added();
        events.add(event);
        mailService.sendMail("jacques@spg1.com", "Event Notification", event
                .toString());
        display.showEvent(event);
    }
The problem with this code, however, comes from what happens in the constructor:
    public Scheduler(String owner, SchedulerDisplay display) {
        this.owner = owner;

        mailService = MailService.getInstance();
        this.display = new SchedulerDisplay();
    }

The display object is associated with a real device (OK, not in our simulation, but you get the point). We need to fix that dependency.

So we traditionally talk about a few ways to address that:
  1. Create an interface and then have a concrete and test-double implementation
  2. Create a test subclass
Those are a few typical ways to handle this problem, but given that the students also worked in C++ and were very concerned with performance (and dynamic binding), so we discussed more alternatives: 1. Link seam – build the system using the original SchedulerDispaly header file but link in a different version of the class. 2. Template parameter (compiler seam) – introduce a template parameter and compile in the dependency rather than link it in.
#pragma once

template<class D> class Scheduler
{
public:
  Scheduler(D &display);
  ~Scheduler();
  void handleEvent();

private:
  D &display;
};
So here are 4 ways to remove the dependency (working bottom up in a sense):
  1. Link seam: link in a different version of SchedulerDisplay
  2. Compiler seam: use a template parameter
  3. Dynamic seam: create a test subclass that removes external dependency
  4. Dynamic seam: extract an interface from existing concrete class, and make Scheduler depend on the new interface.

For C++, the first option might be a good option if it allows a very quick build/test cycle. Imagine using a class that brings in several unwanted dependencies. By making a test version replacement and linking to it, you might be able to get up and running quickly. On the other hand, you have to have a custom build target, which is really outside of the language.

The second option is good for C++ and maybe C#, but not Java. Java’s implementation of generics is so bad, that it requires an interface for this particular case, so you end up with the final option anyway. Using templates puts the seam into the language rather than the build system. It will affect clients because either:
  1. They will have to provide a template parameter
  2. Or, by providing a default value for the template parameter, clients will be aware of a class they were not previously aware of. Still, a viable option, but it will increase build time at least a little.

The third option may not work in any language without changing the original problem code. Imagine a no argument constructor that performs some static initialization. Without changing the constructor, you cannot guarantee that this approach will work. In any case, the problem as presented requires a change since the constructor was doing the initialization of the display; it did not allow for dependency injection.

The final option requires a bit more change, but is pretty flexible if you can afford the virtual method overhead. In Java this isn’t much of an issue (for a number of reasons, mostly related to effective JIT optimization). The cost is a bit more of a problem in C++ because introducing a first virtual method is a big deal. Personally, I don’t work on embedded systems, so I can generally ignore that problem. But this is not something to simply ignore, context does matter.

So which option is the best?

None of the above.

As a developer, you should probably be aware of all of these options (or maybe not the template option of you’re strictly a Java developer). Then, when you are faced with a legacy coding problem, you’ll have more tools from which to choose.

Comments

Leave a response

  1. Avatar
    Cedric about 2 hours later:

    It seems to me the main problem is that the class that contains addEvent() should not know about displays or mail services. I would rewrite it to support listeners or fire an EventAdded event whenever something happens and then have the mail service and the display declare interest in such events.

  2. Avatar
    Matt Baker about 2 hours later:

    This is interesting to me because I’ve been unit testing in C++ for about a year and a half now (after a year and a half in C#). I’m curious, why is introducing a first virtual method a big deal? It’s my understanding that this was how you make “interfaces” in C++, pure virtual functions:

    The first method (if I understand your explanation correctly) is how we do it. If we need to get in the middle of some operation, such as writing output, we encapsulate that behavior and pass in the concrete implementation in the real application, but in unit test code we pass in a “fake” version of it. It contains all the same interfaces but it allows us to capture state, method calls, etc.

    However, this doesn’t come without cost. Because C++ has no nice things like RhinoMocks (oh how I miss thee) we need to build all our “fake” classes by hand. I’ve seen GoogleMock but I haven’t taken the time to learn it. Do you have any experience with it? Also, we call them “Fake” but they’re really just mocks.

  3. Avatar
    Ben Medina about 2 hours later:

    @Cedric: Sure, but this is about legacy code, where the goal is to get existing code under test while making the minimum number of changes. Then you can go about making larger refactorings like you describe.

  4. Avatar
    Eric about 2 hours later:

    I just ran into a similar problem in some legacy Objective-C code. There was a singleton being called like so:

    That’s a pretty common Objective-C idiom for singletons. I was dealing with it via a link seam, but I forsee a problem. Eventually I’m gonna want to get Scheduler itself under test, and now I’ll need a third build target, one that tests scheduler. In a codebase with a lot of these I’ve potentially got a lot of little build targets to create, and now my build times grow…..

    I’m not sure that I had a point to this post – but it’s something worth keeping in mind with link seams.

  5. Avatar
    Steve Py about 3 hours later:

    I find when working with legacy code, option 4 suits 99.9% of cases where I want to introduce some form of regression guard tests. I use a variant to provide optional injection:

    I.e. (C#)

    private IMailService _mailService = null; public IMailService MailService { get { return _mailService ?? NS.MailService.Instance; } set { _mailService = value; } }

    Where NS is the namespace to the original Singleton. This provides a very low impact solution to being able to inject depenedencies with minimal impact. 1) Extract & implement interface from/in Singleton. 2) Replace references to the singleton/private instance with the MailService property. 3) Introduce test stubs for test via the setter.

    In cases where performance is key there’s nothing stopping you from setting the private member for later retrieval in the getter if #null.

  6. Avatar
    Brett L. Schuchert about 8 hours later:

    Cedric,

    Sure, the observer pattern is another option. I might even consider it later, but I don’t think I’d start with it.

    I think I mentioned this was in a class on working with legacy code, so this code has no tests. Our first goal is to make it testable. While the observer pattern does allow for it, it also changes the behavior more than the other options I’ve listed.

    So I might consider that after I’ve done enough to write tests, and I’ve got tests written.

  7. Avatar
    Patrick about 18 hours later:

    Brett,

    As long as there is only one implementation of some interface in a running system, a decent JIT should have no trouble devirtualizing the call and inlining through it, and the runtime can recover (and get slower) if another implementation is loaded afterward. This is especially true if the interface in question is an argument to the method making the call; see: http://citeseerx.ist.psu.edu/viewdoc/summary?doi=10.1.1.58.9784

    So, if you’re talking about having one implementation for production systems and others used only for testing, you should find that performance isn’t a problem. Of course, modern Java apps are incredibly complex, so your mileage may vary.

  8. Avatar
    Brett L. Schuchert about 20 hours later:

    Patric,

    I wrote:
    In Java this isn’t much of an issue (for a number of reasons, mostly related to effective JIT optimization).

    That’s what I was alluding to. In the JVM, there’s really no runtime performance cost to introduce a interface so long as there is just the one concrete implementation loaded by the vm.

    Even if multiple implementations are loaded, but one dominates, the cost can be removed (vm flag to server-side optimizer I believe).

    However, the same cannot be said for C++.

    To be clear, my default preference is to introduce the C++ “interface” – all pure virtual methods with the destructor implemented as well. But that does introduce a vtable and a vtable pointer. Also, for it to be effective, the call must be to a pointer or a reference. So while I don’t consider adding such changes unreasonable by default (though in some situations I can image it being so), it is not as costless as it is in say Java.

    I also forgot to mention that there’s also preprocessor trickery as well (a macro such as TEST_VIRTUAL that is either virtual or blank based on why it is being compiled).

  9. Avatar
    Matt Baker about 24 hours later:

    @Brett

    We’ve tried the preprocessor trick but a lot of people didn’t like it. They felt like it made the code less readable. I’m inclined to agree.

    Also, I take back what I said earlier about being our preference. We either

    a) Extract the dependency out to an interface (purely abstract class) b) Make the would-be concrete implementation the “base class” and have our mock simply override all the necessary methods. Granted, this can be dangerous and confusing if you mess something up. Plus your mocks don’t fail to compile if you add new interfaces to your concrete implementation, but not your mock, like it would with an interface.

    After describing it further…I think ‘a’ our default choice.

  10. Avatar
    Brett L. Schuchert 1 day later:

    @Matt,

    That’s good to know. In fact, most of the places I have gone that use C++ are not doing embedded work (or are, but it’s not “that” embedded). This makes a) a good first chice.

    As for the preprocessor hacks, I agree. There are times in Java where I want a pre-processor, but in general the use of the preprocessor can easily make code awful. Also, if you do have some refactoring tools (I’ve used a few for C++), they typically don’t mingle well with the preprocessor.

  11. Avatar
    Patrick 7 days later:

    @Brett,

    Well, if one subclass dominates, its methods can be inlined if they are guarded with a type test. The cost of the test is not zero, but I take your point.

    Also don’t forget that loading the second implementation of a particular interface can invalidate a lot of code and lead to lots of recompiling.

  12. Avatar
    Rip Blu-ray for Mac 27 days later:

    Blu-ray to iPad- easily convert Blu ray DVD to iPad

  13. Avatar
    VM Ware about 1 month later:

    Michael Feather’s book on legacy code is really informative. I have gone through it . It helped me a lot in my work. In some cases it really solves the problem for once and all. The procedure of fixing the dependency is explained well in the article. All four methods are good on their place if they really help to fix the dependency at least a few times. But as a Java developer our dependency on only these four methods is not desirable.

  14. Avatar
    m2ts to mkv converter 2 months later:

    M2TS to MKV Converter is the best software for user to convert M2TS to MKV file, With the powerful M2TS to MKV converter,you can convert M2TS to MKV with best quality and convert M2TS to all the video formats.m2ts to mkv converter

  15. Avatar
    Buying Money Making Websites 3 months later:

    I used to spend time dealing with these Javascript code issues on my site and then I just started outsourcing the work. It ultimately saves me money because of the time factor…

  16. Avatar
    Halter 4 months later:

    Romance is out of summer, the perfect period. Outing Romantic, melting snow spins dress is today season vogue girls wear build up the important sheet is tasted, using qualitative produce elegant light spins the romantic sense, plus the broken this year popular element , presents different female glamour. The frivolous fabrics spins or cultivate one’s morality is best, clear and elegant texture to help you hide fat shape, block butterfly arm.

  17. Avatar
    Work clothes 4 months later:

    A white coat is white knitting condole belt small unlined upper garment, the snow outside with little organ ruffle capacious fly like a bat sleeve cuff abnormal chic, expand the arc led visual effect, appear very comfortable, add a fair maiden temperament, down the little blue shorts tie-in bright female elegant line, the waist with sleeves extension before joining place adorn, snow spins the style that can give the city offers a lot of inspiration OL people, Dress up the different temperament and successfully leisure and formal, neuter female fusion with proper position.

  18. Avatar
    jingjia 4 months later:

    iPhone Ringtone Custom turns your dream of making your own iPhone/iPhone 3G Ringtone with loved music into reality in the way of converting almost all mainstream video/audio format to M4R iPhone ringtone, such as avi, mpeg, mp4, mov, flv, mp3, aac, m4a, wma, etc. to M4R iPhone Ringtone, even rip DVD Disc to Ringtones for iPhone. Convert to iPhone Ringtone Change iPhone Ringtone Convert Music to iPhone Ringtone Convert MP3 iPhone Ringtone Convert M4A to M4R Convert MP4 to iPhone Ringtone

  19. Avatar
    Youtube to Mp3 online 4 months later:

    Glad I found this article. I love C++

  20. Avatar
    cheap vps 5 months later:

    Michael Feather’s book on legacy code is really informative. I have gone through it . It helped me a lot in my work. In some cases it really solves the problem for once and all. The procedure of fixing the dependency is explained well in the article. All four methods are good on their place if they really help to fix the dependency at least a few times. But as a Java developer our dependency on only these four methods is not desirable.cheap VPS

  21. Avatar
    supplynflshop 5 months later:

    thanks for sharing

  22. Avatar
    adikshoes 6 months later:

    This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives in-depth information.

  23. Avatar
    nikejordanair 6 months later:

    The blog is really appreaciable and i like to keep on visiting this site once again that it would help me in further thanks for sharing the info.

  24. Avatar
    newairjordanhunt 6 months later:

    Thank you for the information I agree with you I became fan of you and would love to visit your blog regularly.

  25. Avatar
    moncler coats 6 months later:

    I think this is very important to somebady.

  26. Avatar
    boots 6 months later:

    Imagine using a class that brings in several unwanted dependencies.Find something new in life.

  27. Avatar
    Chicago mover 6 months later:

    I just love C++ and happy to see such a great explanation.

  28. Avatar
    newwomeninjeans 6 months later:

    Great article though so thanks it’s very interesting you did lot of research before posting any new content.

  29. Avatar
    nhl-nfljerseys 6 months later:

    I don’t have anything else to include on to your article – you basically spelled everything out. great read.

  30. Avatar
    newnikesbdunks 6 months later:

    I would like to thank you for this post. I recently come across your blog and was reading along.

  31. Avatar
    nikedunkhighs 6 months later:

    Thank you for sharing, my families and I all like you article ,reading you article is our best love.

  32. Avatar
    picknikeairmax 6 months later:

    There are some very great sources here and thank you for being so kind to post them here. So we can read them and give our opinion on subject.

  33. Avatar
    Samsung UN40C7000 6 months later:

    Nice, thank for the article abouts Injecting Those Dependencies

  34. Avatar
    Low Glycemic Foods 7 months later:
  35. Avatar
    Cazare in Bucuresti 7 months later:

    This is indeed a very good approach and it works pretty well with my application.

    I was wondering how to use that in conjunction with Zend_Test_PHPUnit_ControllerTestCase. Now, where all controller dependencies are injected using a controller plugin at run time, it seems to be useful to inject mock objects of those dependencies when running a ControllerTestCase. Do you already found a smart way do this?

    From my point of view, it would be nice to directly inject those dependencies from tests’ setUp() method and not running do it via plugins. Garsoniere Regim Hotelier

  36. Avatar
    chanel 7 months later:

    Anybody that votes for a Republican and makes less than $250,000 a year is a FOOL! 30 years of screwing the Middle Class with their Voodoo “Trickle-On” Economics got us to where we are today. Just remember, it was G.W. BUSH who begged Congress to pass TARP and bail out the Big Banks after screwing up everything he got his hands on!

  37. Avatar
    juicy couture tracksuits 7 months later:

    Cosmo, we are not anti union. We just believe to succeed in life, we don’t need to be backed up by a union. We can make on our own abilities. We don’t have to worry about our job being out sourced because we don’t fight to get paid 35 dollars an hour to place a floor mat in a car.

  38. Avatar
    iPad to PC Transfer 8 months later:

    This was a really great info. Check out my blog too.

  39. Avatar
    Satwater Aquarium Light 8 months later:

    public void addEvent(Event event) { event.added(); events.add(event); mailService.sendMail(“”, “Event Notification”, event .toString()); display.showEvent(event); }

    I think this will be a nice code for WP. Thanks!

  40. Avatar
    Racing 8 months later:

    i really like this blog coz it provides lots of useful information from different themes..thanks a lot !!!

  41. Avatar
    morejos.post@gmail.com 8 months later:

    This is a good post. This post give truly quality information.I’m definitely going to look into it.Really very useful tips are provided here.thank you so much.Keep up the good works Orange County Real Estate

  42. Avatar
    One Direction 8 months later:

    hmm.. this is a bit far advanced for me, think i’ll stick to outsourcing my computing work!

  43. Avatar
    ballbusting 8 months later:

    I will t try the above code… hope that works. Thanks!

  44. Avatar
    bare root 8 months later:

    thanks for share this with coding..keep it up buddy.

  45. Avatar
    Apply for fast cash loans 8 months later:

    Thank for providing such a great information and I agree with you all comments. I hope this will be quite essential and important for anyone. You have done a great research and I appreciate your talents.

  46. Avatar
    Pandora 8 months later:

    many of the people on the list have died or disappeared from the political sphere. Several, however, continue to openly support Brown’s campaign.

  47. Avatar
    Ek gelir ?mkanlar? 9 months later:

    Ek gelir ?mkanlar?

    Risk almadan Sermayesiz Evinizden yönetebilece?iniz Kendi i?inizin sahibi olmak istermisiniz ?

  48. Avatar
    Clay Matthews Jersey 9 months later:

    American society of sports among the very popular,Clay Matthews Jerseyespecially in ball games, Jim Plunkett Jerseylike baseball, Packers Jerseybasketball, soccer,Raiders JerseyPenguins Jerseyice hockey, from the young people,Deangelo Hall Jersey to the high school, college,Daunte Culpepper Jersey the whole team has Lian organization and system of the Union ,Darren Mcfadden Jersey while the financial strength of the professional ball alliance,

    • Darrius Heyward Bey Jersey,more about the daily activities of americans.
  49. Avatar
    quebec incorporation 9 months later:

    This post was very well written, and it also contains many useful facts. I appreciated your distinguished manner of writing the post as well because you have made it very easy for us to understand.

  50. Avatar
    ghd hair australia 9 months later:

    Easily change the brightness 80-fuschia pink vibe, the ghd striking styler comes with three pink lip gloss ghd to match every mood, Dare, Dazzle and wise for style and gloss in one gorgeous package.

  51. Avatar
    ??? 9 months later:

    thanks for the topic keep it man

  52. Avatar
    http://www.blacktowhiteiphone4.com 9 months later:

    Looking for the latest white iphone 4 Conversion Kit? I am just looking for a web to satisfy all my need. Come and take it home!

  53. Avatar
    ugg classic cardy boots on sale 9 months later:

    How to negotiate ugg boot sale in the UK, led an advance in Europe. No amount of bazaar or traveling, an anniversary that hit their ugg boots. For men, generally accepted atramentous Ugg boots as his favorite mountain, uggs for sale because they are warm and comfortable, no distress from the cold, feel so safe on the street. For women, ugg flip flop slippers abrasion Ugg boots altered rates evident everywhere. Ugg short general all won by youth, as they may wear clothing altered further sweater too.

  54. Avatar
    ugg classic cardy boots on sale 9 months later:

    How to negotiate ugg boot sale in the UK, led an advance in Europe. No amount of bazaar or traveling, an anniversary that hit their ugg boots. For men, generally accepted atramentous Ugg boots as his favorite mountain, uggs for sale because they are warm and comfortable, no distress from the cold, feel so safe on the street. For women, ugg flip flop slippers abrasion Ugg boots altered rates evident everywhere. Ugg short general all won by youth, as they may wear clothing altered further sweater too.

  55. Avatar
    ugg classic cardy boots on sale 9 months later:

    How to negotiate ugg boot sale in the UK, led an advance in Europe. No amount of bazaar or traveling, an anniversary that hit their ugg boots. For men, generally accepted atramentous Ugg boots as his favorite mountain, uggs for sale because they are warm and comfortable, no distress from the cold, feel so safe on the street. For women, ugg flip flop slippers abrasion Ugg boots altered rates evident everywhere.

  56. Avatar
    Silicone Molding 9 months later:

    Mold making is the core business of Intertech (Taiwan). With world level technology, Intertech enjoys a very good reputation for making Injection Mold and Plastic Moldsfor their worldwide customers.

  57. Avatar
    start swinging 10 months later:

    Thanks for sharing this post with me.I really appreciate your way of presenting this post with a excellent suggestion.I want some more about this article. Since I am the frequent visitor to this blog I will be back here to see more updates in future My best wishes for you.Always keep your excellency and efficiency.

  58. Avatar
    Disater 10 months later:

    Thank you for your nice article. There are many useful information. Thanks

  59. Avatar
    wastewater treatment 10 months later:

    Nice lecture on C+.I know more or less about C.Now I want to learn C+.How should I start?

  60. Avatar
    Sheriff 10 months later:

    A nice job done by Brett Schuchert. thanks for sharing this article here in this website. those C++ informations are really useful. – sit up bar

  61. Avatar
    hair extensions suppliers 10 months later:

    hair extension suppliers Hey ladies for the DMV area, I do hope that with summer months coming along, vacations will be in order and maybe hair manufacturers we can plan a meet up day. I am new as well to LF, I havent worn one however am anxiously waiting for my first application..lol..

    At this time I am out of the country for school in Japan, so once I get back I will be able to join a meet up.

    This is an awesome thread and I hope we can all help one anothe human hair manufacturers

  62. Avatar
    doctor Los Angeles 10 months later:

    it is great what you did… in this way our application will be secured.

  63. Avatar
    Cardoza 10 months later:

    Great work done by Brett Schucher by sharing this topic “Injecting those Dependencies” on C++. thanks for this useful article – Health insurance quote

  64. Avatar
    Jefferson 10 months later:

    This was an awesome post. good article by Brett Schuchert. i tried this and got worked. thanks for this informative article – inspirational quotes

  65. Avatar
    IC componenets 10 months later:

    good place to get IC componenets – partinchina.com

  66. Avatar
    hair extensions suppliers 10 months later:

    3.will i ever feel i have enough hair in my stash 4.why do i check my tracking # from the post office 5.will EP ever offer more than a 15% discount

  67. Avatar
    Martin 11 months later:

    really very informative article. good job by Brett Schuchert. thanks for sharing here. this article was very much useful for C++ developers. – Doppel-Stegplatten

  68. Avatar
    vacature 11 months later:

    The blog are the main media of knowing about the world that what is going on in this world and what is gonna be. this is one of the best that kind of blog which has lot of those information which everyone like to have. I personally like to thank to this blog.

  69. Avatar
    pokersidor 11 months later:

    Great job done by Brett Schuchert by sharing this informative article. this informations surely helpful for C++ developers. – pokersidor

  70. Avatar
    iPhone SMS to Mac Backup 11 months later:

    Would you like to banckup iphone SMS to mac, macBook, macbookPro as .txt files? Now a software iphone SMS to Mac Backup can help you to realize it.

  71. Avatar
    http://www.instantloansneed.co.uk/ 11 months later:

    Great post and information. It was a nice read and very useful. Thanks for posting.

  72. Avatar
    http://www.instantloansneed.co.uk/ 11 months later:

    Nice information. Very useful code. Thanks for sharing.

  73. Avatar
    software license management 11 months later:

    this was an excellent post. really useful tips and instructions for developers. thanks for Brett Schuchert for sharing this informative article here – software license management

  74. Avatar
    Restaurants Kansas City 11 months later:

    This site really great because here post so good and interesting. Thank you very much for this post. Restaurants Kansas City

  75. Avatar
    Joel 11 months later:

    thanks for sharing this helpful article. really the points and instructions shared here are very useful for the C++ developers. good job done by Brett Schuchert. – webdesign

  76. Avatar
    cable ties 12 months later:

    very helpful article. great ideas.

  77. Avatar
    ssara 12 months later:

    These techniques are so much confusing for me. Pennsylvania Foreclosure Help

  78. Avatar
    Insurance leads 12 months later:

    This site really great because here post so good and interesting.Thank you very much for this post. Insurance leads

  79. Avatar
    website design denver 12 months later:

    This site really great because here post so good and interesting.Thank you very much for this post. website design denver

  80. Avatar
    dswehfhh 12 months later:

    We are the professional coats manufacturer, coats supplier, coats factory, custom coats.

  81. Avatar
    George 12 months later:

    this was an amazing article. really this article is useful. great work by Brett Schuchert. thanks for sharing the informations here – social media vancouver

  82. Avatar
    James smith 12 months later:

    informative topic on injecting those dependancies. really these informations shared here are very helpful for c++ developers – diatpillen

  83. Avatar
    Deona 12 months later:

    very informative article on the topic injecting those dependencies. this article was much helpful for the c++ developers. – custom greek

  84. Avatar
    ????? ?????? about 1 year later:

    this was an excellent post. really useful tips and instructions for

  85. Avatar
    work from home coach about 1 year later:

    Excellent work, We should all learn from this I’m not sure I agree with all the comments here, but there are some interesting poits of view

    Squeeze Page Templates ¦ Work from home coach ¦ prado e-cig free trial

  86. Avatar
    Auto Affiliate Payout about 1 year later:

    Dont Forget to Buy Auto Affiliate Payout

  87. Avatar
    Amazon Kindle 3 Review about 1 year later:

    This sounds really great..

  88. Avatar
    Amazon Kindle 3 Review about 1 year later:

    ANyway I agree with you auto affiliate payout.

  89. Avatar
    refrigerant about 1 year later:

    Thanks for the information…great blog

  90. Avatar
    irfan about 1 year later:

    good

  91. Avatar
    dory about 1 year later:

    Great stuff from you. very useful information, thank you. Social Network I’ve read your stuff before and you’re just too awesome.

  92. Avatar
    steve about 1 year later:

    This code is so confusing. What parameters are you using below the first paragraph?

    shogun vs jones fight video

  93. Avatar
    thank you gifts about 1 year later:

    Amazing poster.good work.v ill look further Nice post, I am sure to come bach again in future … Hey, nice art i add your blog to my rss!

  94. Avatar
    Sarah about 1 year later:

    Very cool. I just started to learning C++ and I am really enjoying it so far.

    Sarah likes TurboTax Free

  95. Avatar
    Seobaglyak about 1 year later:

    I enjoyed reading this article!!!

  96. Avatar
    Aaron Briggs about 1 year later:

    This is great stuff. I have to say i am impressed by your ideas. roofing contractor venice

  97. Avatar
    Best golf simulator about 1 year later:

    You still have to learn a lot man. btw thanks for sharing the difficulties u faced while programing.

  98. Avatar
    Job Vacancies Abroad about 1 year later:

    C++ as a programming language is less and less popular. More and more people prefer object oriented languages. An option for C++ programmers is always seeking job vacancies abroad.

  99. Avatar
    Job Vacancies Abroad about 1 year later:

    C++ is getting less popluar, object oriented languages are on the rise. But an option for C++ programmers are job vacancies abroad.

  100. Avatar
    cash fast get loan personal requirement about 1 year later:

    A great blog for everybody. It is fantastic and full of information.Keep up the good work guys!!! And continue making blogs that are very useful for everybody. God Bless!! cash fast get loan personal requirement

  101. Avatar
    cash fast get loan personal requirement about 1 year later:

    Great info! I recently came across your blog and have been reading along. I thought I would leave my first comment. I don’t know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading. Nice blog.

  102. Avatar
    Scott about 1 year later:

    Thank you for your nice article. There are many useful information. Thanks

  103. Avatar
    How to have a boy about 1 year later:

    I’m a C++ developer and this post is very informative,thanks

  104. Avatar
    network hard drive about 1 year later:

    I am curious who can we do it in Objective C… I want to protect the applications for smart devices.

  105. Avatar
    lightyear wireless about 1 year later:

    problem was solved.

  106. Avatar
    Skjuwel about 1 year later:

    The post is written in very a good manner and it entails many useful information for me. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. content management

  107. Avatar
    Skjuwel about 1 year later:

    A great blog for everybody. It is fantastic and full of information.Keep up the good work guys!!! And continue making blogs that are very useful for everybody. God Bless!!

  108. Avatar
    dallmeier electronic about 1 year later:

    The info provided in the above article is very amazing and this article belong to very fantastic and update info. thanks dallmeier electronic

  109. Avatar
    Jeff Foster about 1 year later:

    I’ve never considered creating a test sub-class to fix a dependency problem, but it sounds like a more elegant solution than double implementation. Of course with the newer websites I have fewer and fewer C++ dependencies to confront on a weekly basis, for which I am endlessly thankful!

  110. Avatar
    Ramzes1 about 1 year later:

    T mobile internet

  111. Avatar
    Josieklein07 about 1 year later:

    Constructor is a member function whose member function are same but is has no return data type.Constructor is automatically call when object of any class is call. marble richmond

  112. Avatar
    Nike Max Sale about 1 year later:

    Adoption of Test driven development technique is an important requirement for new developer.

  113. Avatar
    beats by dr dre headphones about 1 year later:

    I attempted these beats by dr dre studio out in several genres thinking about which i listen to an eclectic mix Beats By Dr Dre. a washing cloth as well as the manual. Do not purchase any beats by dr dre solo purple products inside the internet unless you’re getting from an Authorized internet DealerBeats By Dre Just Solo. We are reliable provide good beats by dr dre pro black by reduced price.

  114. Avatar
    car colour about 1 year later:

    From my point of view, it would be nice to directly inject those dependencies from tests’ setUp() method and not running do it via plugins.

  115. Avatar
    Flat Roofing about 1 year later:

    The procedure of fixing the dependency is explained well in the article. All four methods are good on their place if they really help to fix the dependency at least a few times.

  116. Avatar
    design and print about 1 year later:

    I was dealing with it via a link seam, but I forsee a problem. Eventually I’m gonna want to get Scheduler itself under test, and now I’ll need a third build target, one that tests scheduler.

  117. Avatar
    Cookies Gift about 1 year later:

    Blog posts about wedding and bridal are always rare to find , at least with great quality,you qualify for a great blog post writer title,kep the great job happening

  118. Avatar
    onlinesolutionproviders about 1 year later:
    This is nice post and sprituly encourges others becuase under standing value excellnt last when web site i read post i real inspired and suddenly bookmar many friends share me information

    HomeWork Help

  119. Avatar
    onlinesolutionproviders about 1 year later:
    This is nice post and sprituly encourges others becuase under standing value excellnt last when web site i read post i real inspired and suddenly bookmar many friends share me information

    HomeWork Help

  120. Avatar
    Excellent Post! about 1 year later:

    That’s really a great post for the student of c++ developers.I am starting the learning of C++ and it’s really great subject.Your page also provide me a useful information.Thanks for sharing the information with us. web analytics software

  121. Avatar
    cmms jobs about 1 year later:

    Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information and I will be waiting for other interesting posts from you in the nearest future. keep it up.

  122. Avatar
    cmms jobs about 1 year later:

    Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information and I will be waiting for other interesting posts from you in the nearest future. keep it up.

  123. Avatar
    cmms jobs about 1 year later:

    I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the post. Now you make it easy for me to understand and implement the concept. cmms jobs

  124. Avatar
    http://www.wholesalejerseyshut.com/goods/St.-Louis-Rams--8-Sam-Bradford-Team-Color-blue-Jersey-10414.html about 1 year later:

    ””“Thanks for sharing this useful information! Hope that you will continue with the kind of stuff you are doing.”””

  125. Avatar
    <a href="http://www.wholesalejerseyshut.com/"><strong>wholesale mlb jerseys></a> about 1 year later:

    Good day.. Here are very great comments but no more great than your post. its really great. Thanks

  126. Avatar
    America's Got Talent Silhouettes about 1 year later:

    I have to say this post was certainly informative and contains useful content for enthusiastic visitors. I will definitely bookmark this blog for future reference and further viewing. Thanks a bunch for sharing this with us!

  127. Avatar
    ????? ?????? about 1 year later:

    rgre

  128. Avatar
    reizen naar india about 1 year later:

    C + + is increasingly popular, object-oriented languages ??are on the rise. However, an option for developers of C + + are the jobs abroad.

  129. Avatar
    ????? ???? ????? about 1 year later:

    Thanks a lot for sharing this useful and attractive information and I will be waiting for other interesting posts from you in the nearest future. keep it up. :)

  130. Avatar
    coupon for baby about 1 year later:

    I really enjoyed reading this post. I congratulate you for the terrific job that you’re doing. Great stuff, just simply amazing!

  131. Avatar
    iowa Foreclosures Central about 1 year later:

    I agree with the entire comment above.I like your post and all you share with us is up todate and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.

  132. Avatar
    matisse about 1 year later:

    This is very useful suggestions. I have to say I love reading this alot. It can help me to turn into better grasp about the subject. It is all well and good written. I shall definitely search for these satisfied incredibly engaging. I hope you could supply more sooner or later.

  133. Avatar
    Grand Island Rent To Own about 1 year later:

    This is very useful suggestions. I have to say I love reading this alot. It can help me to turn into better grasp about the subject. It is all well and good written. I shall definitely search for these satisfied incredibly engaging. I hope you could supply more sooner or later.

  134. Avatar
    Denver Foreclosure Central about 1 year later:

    blog as it is just what I’ve looking for and excited to read all the posts. I am looking forward to another great article from you.

  135. Avatar
    alanmecn about 1 year later:

    This is a great blog posting and very helpful. I really appreciate the research you put into welding machineryhis blog.

  136. Avatar
    Rent To Own Omaha about 1 year later:

    I just wanted to say hi and tell you how wonderful I think your blog is. I am a latecomer, unfortunately—but I will keep a close eye on it, now that I have found it. Take care

  137. Avatar
    Nebraska Foreclosures Central about 1 year later:

    I’m happy for I found this blog, explaining everything in detail regarding the topic. We can benefit from these articles and I wish we do not have a language barrier.I Will probably be back to get more.

  138. Avatar
    homer rent to own denver about 1 year later:

    This is very useful suggestions. I have to say I love reading this alot. It can help me to turn into better grasp about the subject. It is all well and good written. I shall definitely search for these satisfied incredibly engaging. I hope you could supply more sooner or later.

  139. Avatar
    Urgent Care Omaha about 1 year later:

    So informative things are provided here,I really happy to read this post,I was just imagine about it and you provided me the correct information I really bookmark it,for further reading.

  140. Avatar
    Health Care about 1 year later:

    Java’s implementation of generics is so bad, that it requires an interface for this particular case, so you end up with the final option anyway.

  141. Avatar
    Upcoming games about 1 year later:

    I agree with the entire comment above.I like your post and all you share with us is up todate and quite informative, i would like to bookmark the page so i can come here again to read you, as you have done a wonderful job.

  142. Avatar
    sex about 1 year later:

    This was a really great info. Check out my blog too.

  143. Avatar
    bagsupplyer about 1 year later:

    Nice Article.Thank you for sharing. Waiting for updating. Cheap brand men Diesel t shirt from China for wholesale at on line store

  144. Avatar
    bagsupplyer about 1 year later:

    Thank you for posting. Waiting for updating. Discount designer men DSQ t shirt from China at on line store

  145. Avatar
    Nebraska Foreclosures Central about 1 year later:

    I’m happy for I found this blog, explaining everything in detail regarding the topic. We can benefit from these articles and I wish we do not have a language barrier.I Will probably be back to get more.

  146. Avatar
    Rent To Own Omaha about 1 year later:

    I just wanted to say hi and tell you how wonderful I think your blog is. I am a latecomer, unfortunately-but I will keep a close eye on it,now that I have found it. Take care!!!

  147. Avatar
    Omaha Foreclosure Central about 1 year later:

    I want to say that this article is awesome, nice written and include almost all vital infos. I would like to see more posts like this .

  148. Avatar
    coupon for baby about 1 year later:

    So informative this are provided here,I really happy to read this post,I was just imagine about it and you provided me the correct informg,So thanks for sharing the information.

  149. Avatar
    Latest Movie Poster about 1 year later:

    I really enjoyed reading this post. I congte you for the terrific job that you’re doing. Great stuff, just simply amazing!

  150. Avatar
    http://www.ghalay.com about 1 year later:

    I need to read more on this topic…I admiring time and effort you put in your blog, because it is obviously one great place where I can find lot of useful info.. http://www.ghalay.com

  151. Avatar
    UGG Montclair about 1 year later:

    The article in UGG Montclair Boots Saleyour blog reminds me some old memory .That is good .It gives me happy .I think we will haMontclair UGG Boots Saleous talk.Do you agree?

  152. Avatar
    Christian about 1 year later:

    as vbcn+0v b+vcb n+v

  153. Avatar
    moncler about 1 year later:

    asdfa sd0+fa+0s d9sdss

  154. Avatar
    Louboutins about 1 year later:

    asda s d60f4as5+d6 sss

  155. Avatar
    ????? ?????? about 1 year later:

    Parkour and Freerunning are different but not entirely. Parkour was disciplined anterior to Freerunning by David Belle. It consists of hurdles and bounds. The big philosophical system

  156. Avatar
    ????? ?????? about 1 year later:

    ely. Parkour was disciplined anterior to Freerunning by David Belle. It consists of hurdles and bounds. The big philosophical system

  157. Avatar
    sex about 1 year later:

    Do all these people just need to vent? Well that’s my two cents! Have a great day!

  158. Avatar
    bakiretr about 1 year later:

    Thank you for taking the time to publish this information very useful!I’m still waiting for some interesting thoughts from your side in your next post

  159. Avatar
    Ashley Bowling about 1 year later:

    No matter what the problem is, it’s always a people problem.

    Jerry Weinberg
  160. Avatar
    ysbearing/yisong@1stbearing.com about 1 year later:

    Slewing ring is also called slewing bearing, some people called: rotary support, swing support. English Name: slewing bearing or slewing ring bearing or turn table bearing, slewing ring in the real industrial applications is very wide. http://www.1stbearing.com

  161. Avatar
    No Hype iPhone 4S Features about 1 year later:

    I’m happy for I found this blog, explaining everything in detail regarding the topic. We can benefit from these articles and I wish we do not have a language barrier.I Will probably be back to get more.

    No Hype iPhone 4S Features

  162. Avatar
    No Hype iPhone 4S Features about 1 year later:

    I think the article very interesting and above all true and applicabile.Il blog is well done and nice, congratulations. No Hype iPhone 4S Features

  163. Avatar
    Nascar Racing about 1 year later:

    Please email me with any hints & tips about how you made your website look this good, I would appreciate it.

  164. Avatar
    Wood Floor Dallas about 1 year later:

    Remodeling floors will go a long way in setting the ambiance of the room. Materials are available in a variety of textures and styles such as hardwood flooring, laminate, and ceramics. Materials must be durable and skid resistant to withstand high traffic while still remaining comfortable underfoot. Choice Flooring and Remodelling Brings you the best services yet pocket friendly!

  165. Avatar
    Rubel about 1 year later:

    Reading through this your publish I’ve known many something totally new relating to this new great version from the ” new world ” that we haven’t known before. No Hype iPhone 4S Features

  166. Avatar
    Brokerage firms about 1 year later:

    I am happy when reading your blog with updated information! thanks alot and hope that you will post more site that are related to this site.

  167. Avatar
    Gold Price about 1 year later:

    With the help of golden prices we can buy all things which we have desire. Gold Price

  168. Avatar
    Depression counselling London about 1 year later:

    From my point of view, it would be nice to directly inject those dependencies from tests’ setUp() method and not running do it via plugins.

  169. Avatar
    lipozene about 1 year later:

    This site is really appreciated..Thanks for sharing this site with us..!

  170. Avatar
    Austin Computer Repair over 2 years later:

    This blog has published some important codes that can help me to overcome some problems.These codes are really important.Thanks for sharing this blog.

    Austin Computer Repair

  171. Avatar
    Injection mold over 2 years later:

    Intertech Machinery Inc. provides the most precise Plastic Injection Mold and Rubber Molds from Taiwan. With applying excellent unscrewing device in molds,

    Intertech is also very professional for making flip top Cap Molds in the world. Mold making is the core business of Intertech (Taiwan). With world level technology, Intertech enjoys a very good reputation for making Injection Mold and Plastic Molds for their worldwide customers.

Comments