The CSM Integrity Deficit 127

Posted by Uncle Bob Fri, 18 Sep 2009 13:44:43 GMT

Scott Ambler wrote a blog, and an editorial about the dirty dealings and desperate deception of the Scrum Alliance and their slimy certification scam. He rightly points out that the certification means little more than the applicant’s check didn’t bounce.

He goes on to imply that the entire agile community is guilty of keeping silent while this huge chicanery was foisted upon an innocent industry. He calls this conspiratorial silence: “integrity debt”.

Oh bollux! What an incredible load of Dingoes Kidneys!

Look. I’m not a big fan of CSM. I think it’s a gimmick. I am not a CSM myself, and have no intention of joining their ranks. When I meet someone who proclaims themselves to be a CSM, I’m not particularly impressed. I know what that certification means, and I take it with a grain of salt. To me, the title of CSM is worth little more than a shrug.

We at Object Mentor do a lot of training in things like Test Driven Development, Agile Methods. Object Oriented Principles, Java, C#, etc. etc. At the end of every course we often sign and pass out certificates to the students. Those certificates proclaim that the student attended the course. I see no difference between that certificate (which is a certification after all) and the CSM certificate. I suppose the students who take our TDD course could claim to be Object Mentor Certified TDDers; and they’d be right.

Have we created an “Integrity Debt” by handing out those certificates? Of course not. Everybody knows exactly what they mean. Nobody misrepresents their intent. They are an honest statement of fact. And the same is true of the CSM certificate.

Is it troubling that some HR people are starting to put CSM requirements on Job postings? Not at all! It is perfectly within the rights of any company to decide that they want to hire people who have been appropriately trained. Are there some HR people who overestimate the value of CSM? Probably, but that’s their own fault.

In my humble opinion there is no significant integrity issue here. Oh it wouldn’t surprise me to learn that there might have been some back-door deals in the early days of CSM. Perhaps some people were given CST status, or CSM status without careful controls. If that happened, I chalk it up to birthing pains which the Scrum Alliance is striving to correct. I don’t think anybody was out to scam anybody else. I don’t think CSM is a far flung conspiracy to ruin the software industry, and I don’t think the US government flew those jets into the twin towers.

Bottom line. There is no “Integrity Debt” here. What there is is a group of honest and caring folks who are trying to figure out the best ways to get Agile concepts adopted in an industry that sorely needs them.

In that regard I think that the agile movement has enjoyed a significant boost because of the interest generated by the CSM program. There are more companies doing Agile today because of CSM. So if anybody owes a debt here, it may be the Agile community owing a debt to the CSM program.

Maybe, instead of accusing and castigating and pointing the finger of judgement and doom we ought give a salute to Ken Schwaber, and say: “Thanks Ken.”

Comments

Leave a response

  1. Avatar
    Scott Duncan 16 minutes later:

    I agree on all accounts.

    I do think a claim of “certification” should meet certain criteria for it to have some value so as not to cheapen the idea of what a certification in other fields requires.

    However, there is no question that Scrum has become the most prominent view of an agile approach, whether people even use that method name, usually combined with XP technical practices.

    There has been concern expressed over people losing their ability to practice in an agile coaching/training fashion if they must become certified in some way. However, that will be because the industry wants to use such certification(s) as a way to simplify their seartch for employees/consultants.

    To me, it is not much different from a company insisting on a college degree to do work where years of experience has probably prepared a person better for such work. (I am still asked to supply a college transcript to even do adjunct, part-time teaching at local colleges in areas where I have years of experience and references. It’s from 1969 for gosh sakes!)

  2. Avatar
    KevDog 34 minutes later:

    Dear Uncle Bob,

    It’s clear that among many HR departments,especially those in the corporate IT world, certifications have become a proxy for experience. They are used as a quick and dirty way to pare down the resume mountain. Can’t really blame them for that.

    Personally, I choose to see them as a proxy for individual motivation. At some point the person either took the time to either bug their boss about it and get the training or shelled out the ducats to pay for it themselves. In any case, the interview process can reveal their actual motivation for attending as well as the depth of their knowledge.

    There is a difference between certification and training, however. What you offer is training and you make no claims on the level of expertise the attendees leave with. As I am currently pestering my boss to put ObjectMentor on the training list, I have a fairly good idea what I would get out of it but I wouldn’t think that I could make a claim other than that I had attended the training.

    But what the CSM and PMP people are doing is stating that the certifications give the holders a level of job fitness. Having a PMP cert myself, I can unequivocally state it was the biggest waste of time and money since I bought a Yugo in college. It made me no better suited for any particular work. Being able to pass a three-hour multiple choice test isn’t something I think I’m going to need to do again soon. The only thing holding a PMP did was get me past the resume screen. Ironic, since I was leaving PM work to return to programming.

    Maybe I’m bitter about the PMP thing, but to me the main beneficiaries of the certs are the organizations that profit from people getting their piece of paper.

    You are right, there isn’t an integrity deficit, merely a misguided way of allowing people to demonstrate job fitness. But it’s better than nothing.

  3. Avatar
    Sebastian Kübeck ht about 2 hours later:

    Bob, thank you for pointing this out! Nothing further to add.

  4. Avatar
    Marcel Popescu about 2 hours later:

    When it comes to certifications of any kind, I cannot help but agree with Heinlein’s proposal to grant every Californian a college diploma – as he said, it doesn’t cost anything and doesn’t hurt anybody. It’s not like the “real” diplomas mean anything.

  5. Avatar
    Scott Duncan about 2 hours later:

    Just had an experience bearing on the meaningfulness of certifications and people’s understanding of them relative to simply matching them to job specs.

    A headhunter called me saying he had a client looking for someone who was a Certified Scrum Coach, Certified Scrum Trtainer, [or?] Certified ScrumMaster. He had no clue what these were about, of course. Worst part was he seemed not to know what his supposed client thought they wanted out of people with such qualifications.

    I will say, overall, that, in the software, many certifications seem to carry little value because of the way one earns them. I believe some require years of experience, but few organizations even verify that. I have been told that PMI randomly audits some % of their applicants to verify pre-test qualifications like education and experience. But I’m not aware of any software-specific ones that do this. At least this seems true at the “entry” level which is what most are, i.e., they are the one and only level of certification offered in that domain by the specific body granting the certification.

  6. Avatar
    Philip Schwarz about 4 hours later:

    Also from Uncle Bob: Dirty Rotten ScrumDrels

  7. Avatar
    David@Scrumology about 5 hours later:

    I think I approached this backwards, being that I’ve been involved in Agile since late 2002, but only recently got CSM. I kept in touch with others from CSM class who had no prior experience, they ran out and tried it, and got fired.

    I used CSM to supplement and redirect bad habits I had learned from Trial by Fire Agile™. You know, those tech startup jobs where it’s a multi-million dollar project, you are using Agile, and the fate of the company depends on it? Yeah those introduce bad habits under pressure.

    However, you cannot deny the data behind the use of Agile & Scrum in job postings: http://www.scrumology.net/2009/06/18/agile-and-scrum-trend-analysis/

    As long as you can parse through the HR-speak, it isn’t hard to find the real Agile job opportunities, and CSM on your resume doesn’t hurt!

    Btw I also disagree with Mr Ambler about 99% of the time.

    -David

  8. Avatar
    William Pietri about 5 hours later:

    Hi, Bob. Here’s my reasoning on why this is bad.

    As somebody who has spent quite a while encouraging people to adopt Agile methods, in the minds of other people, I am inevitably associated with both successes and failures they see under that label. Further, to the extent I want to use that label in the future, I have an incentive to make sure that not too much idiocy happens under the Agile banner.

    But I have met a number of people who believe that a Certified Scrum Master means that the holder is a certified master of Scrum. You and I don’t think a two-day course qualifies you to be much of anything, sure. But the whole point of a certification is to abstract away the details, so you don’t have to be an insider to evaluate the certificate-holder.

    To the extent a hiring manager could reasonably perceive the CSM as the Agile community saying that the holder is qualified for something, I think we are at fault. And regardless, we will end up paying some of the price for their mistakes, so fault or no, I think it’s in our interest to improve the situation.

  9. Avatar
    Tim VanFosson about 6 hours later:

    I would agree. Most, if not all, of the certifications in the IT industry are merely paper signifying attendance at a course. This is, or should be, well known in hiring circles and among practitioners. The quality of courses vary and some certifications may have more or less merit than others, but they shouldn’t be mistaken for actual capabilities or expertise. People doing the hiring should know enough to say “I see you’ve taken the course, now what did you learn and how have you applied it?”

  10. Avatar
    Philip Schwarz 1 day later:

    I just came across the following, which claims to be ‘the web’s most popular scrum video!’:

    SCRUM in Under 10 Minutes (also available in High Definition!).

    Does it cover all one needs to know to get certified?

  11. Avatar
    Ken Schwaber 3 days later:

    Well said … Thanks, Bob. Ken

  12. Avatar
    Michael Maham 4 days later:

    Bob-

    Great post! I was writing up some similar thoughts (http://lessmayhemmoresoftware.blogspot.com/2009/09/more-agile-certification-talk.html) when I read your post.

    I heard some chatter wagering that IBM will soon unveil their own Agile certification. It will be interesting to see if that comes about.

    michael

  13. Avatar
    Rodrigo Yoshima 5 days later:

    It’s not that simple. Object Mentor doesn’t claim to be the “official” Test-Driven Development course. If the “Test-Driven Alliance” creates something like “TDCP”, and the “official” course and the “official” certification/certificate you will change your opinion.

    The problem with ScrumAlliance is that they claim to be the “official” training, making all other courses looking like poor quality or something like that.

    I teach about Agile and Scrum here in Brazil and I don’t have any plans to be CST because I don’t agree with ScrumAlliance’s vision about Agile training. Just that.

  14. Avatar
    Marcelo L 8 days later:

    Do I think myself some mystic because I DO have my CSM, and don’t regret it ? No. Do I think myself perhaps more prepared for certain challenges than the average bear who thinks himself an agile practitioner ? Yes.

    @Rodrigo: What exactly of the Scrum Alliance’s “Vision” is it you don’t agree with. I love it when folks make blanket statements, but just happen…to leave out specifics.

    As for whether Object Mentor could claim to be “official” Test-Driven Development certifiers….well then maybe they’d have to open themselves up to more community governance about what constitutes pragmatic best practices to employ in TDD. If you’ve been around this place long enough, and read some of the comments of TDD practitioners you’d know that not all “are of one mind” either.

    If the Scrum Alliance is so “off” by certifing “official” trainers. What’s to stop others from granting official CISCO, or Microsoft of Sun certifications ? Governance. The Scrum Alliance applies governance over the process of qualifying those who are both up to date with the goals and direction of Scrum, who’ve built up a body of traceable experience in coaching and training, and continue to do so.

    Geeze, the way you put it, anyone who’s been programming Windows for over 20 years like I have could call myself a Microsoft Certified Trainer. Yeah, let me try to pull that one off, and see how far I’d get before I got phone calls from Redmond. C’mon, talk some sense.

    The difference is governance. If you don’t agree with what the Scrum Alliance is working towards, fine. You’re more than welcome to NOT become certified to any capacity you don’t wish to be. Then again, I’d have to wonder what students would be learning from someone who isn’t certified by somebody else in practices they’re purporting to bestow upon others.

  15. Avatar
    Jon Kern 20 days later:

    The world will sort this out… Welcome to free enterprise. If HR folks decide to use a piece of paper as a measure of something important to them, and it doesn’t yield the desired results, they will adapt.

    If folks hire people based solely on a piece of paper, they’ll get inconsistent results, and be free to change their ways. Or not.

    A 2-day course to get a certificate or four years at a college to get a certificate… neither truly represent the ability of an individual to perform in a certain capacity at a certain organization on a specific project.

    IMHO, there isn’t much to get in a huff about… move along.

    BTW: I am UML Certified and I didn’t take any course (just helped James Odell beta test the exam)! The certification does not test if you can model, but only that you know the syntax of the modeling elements. BFD.

  16. Avatar
    Daniel Sobral 27 days later:

    @Marcelo L:

    To get certified with ITIL or PMI you have to pass written tests. To get a CISCO certification you have to pass written tests and, for the more advanced stuff, actual lab tests.

    To get certified with Scrum, you just have to pay.

    That’s the crux of the matter.

    Of course, most certifications are barely useful. They can be used to discard the completely incompetent, but can still be had by a wide array of inadequate people. And, of course, they never stand for excellence.

    I open an exception here for the Cisco certifications with lab work.

  17. Avatar
    proxy sites 2 months later:

    Going to play with it, right away. Will post updates. Cool bit.

  18. Avatar
    UGG Classic Metallicaz` 6 months later:

    welcome to http://www.uggboots4buy.com/ l,will have a unexpection.

  19. Avatar
    Kooba Handbags 6 months later:

    Living without an aim is like sailing without a compass. with a new http://www.handbags4buy.com/ idea is a crank until the idea succeeds.

  20. Avatar
    han 7 months later:

    http://www.ipadvideoconverters.biz iPad Video Converter iPad Video Converter is a great software for iPad lovers to convert videos to iPad with super fast speed and high quality. Its easy-to-use interface makes iPad to videos conversion routine very simple. And also it can keep the original quality of video files.

  21. Avatar
    Fitness Network 9 months later:

    great article on health and fitness.

  22. Avatar
    louis vuitton 9 months later:

    Well , the view of the passage is totally correct ,your details is really reasonable and you guy give us valuable informative post, I totally agree the standpoint of upstairs . http://www.precision-mechanical.net I often surfing on this forum when I m free and I find there are so much good information we can learn in this forum!

  23. Avatar
    simulation assurance auto 9 months later:

    I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike additional blogs I have read which are really not good. I also found your posts very interesting. In fact after reading, I had to go show it to my friend and he enjoyed it as well!

  24. Avatar
    Airport Taxi Transfers To From Airport 10 months later:

    This is an excellent topic you are discussing about and i really appreciate it. It should be going on.

  25. Avatar
    Crinoline skirt 10 months later:

    Romance is out of summer, the perfect period. Outing Romantic, melting snow spins dress is today season vogue girls wear build up the important sheet is tasted, using qualitative produce elegant light spins the romantic sense, plus the broken this year popular element , presents different female glamour. The frivolous fabrics spins or cultivate one’s morality is best, clear and elegant texture to help you hide fat shape, block butterfly arm.

  26. Avatar
    Chemise dress 10 months later:

    In this summer, the romantic and small, is confronted dragon-boat festival holiday for a picnic superexcellent period. Romantic, melting snow spins dress is today season vogue girls wear build up the important sheet is tasted, using qualitative produce elegant light spins the romantic sense, plus the broken this year popular element , presents different female glamour.

  27. Avatar
    liding rode 10 months later:

    OK, I got it. Thanks for your sharing. That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this.

  28. Avatar
    jingjia 10 months later:

    MTS Converter can help you to convert mts files easily and quickly, and it is very easy to use. if you are in need, you can download it and experience by yourself.

    Main Features of MTS Converter

    • Convert AVC HD(.MTS) to all standard video formats like AVI, WMV, MPG, MOV, DVD, etc and various audio files like AAC, AC3, MP3, WAV, WMA, etc.
    • Support batch conversion, you can import more input mts files to the file playlist
    • Provide rich profiles, customize and save your profile for future use
    • Capture current pictures by click “snapshot” and save the current image to snapshot folder
    • Supports extract audio, pictures from video
    • Split one source file to several
  29. Avatar
    Youtube to Mp3 10 months later:

    Really glad I cam across this site. It has been so useful

  30. Avatar
    ugly boots 10 months later:

    OK, I got it. Thanks for your sharing. That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like this

  31. Avatar
    rocku 11 months later:

    I really loved reading your blog. It was very well authored and easy to understand. Unlike additional blogs I have read which are really not good.

  32. Avatar
    cheap vps 11 months later:

    OK, I got it. Thanks for your sharing. That is very interesting Smile I love reading and I am always searching for informative information like thischeap VPS

  33. Avatar
    devenir consultant 11 months later:

    You are right, there isn’t an integrity deficit, merely a misguided way of allowing people to demonstrate job fitness. But it’s better than nothing.

  34. Avatar
    supplynflshop 12 months later:

    interesting thanks for sharing

  35. Avatar
    goodymary 12 months later:

    Mac iPad Video Converter is iPad Video Converter working on Mac OS X. It is specially-designed video converter to convert any popular video file (You tube, TS, TOD, MKV, MTS, AVI, FLV, WMV, MPG, M4V, RM, MOV, etc.) to iPad video MP4, MPEG, H.264 on Mac with high speed and great quality. When you free download videos from youtube.com and you want to enjoy them on your iPad. Here Mac YouTube to iPad Converter is suitable for you. You can convert any YouTube videos to iPad MP4 video formats. Mac AVI to iPad Converter is necessary for us to have a try, which can help you convert all AVI videos and other popular video formats like WMV, 3GP, MPEG, VOB, FLV, Xvid to iPad supported MP4 video format. Mac MOV to iPad Converter is your best choice to convert MOV files to iPad MP4

  36. Avatar
    best blu ray converter 12 months later:

    Blu Ray Converter can easily convert blu ray dvd/common dvd/DVD IFO file/DVD folder/DVD ISO file to most common Video, HD Video, Flash Video, iPod, iPhone, iPad, Apple TV, PSP/PS3, Creative Zen, BlackBerry, Zune, Xbox, Mobile Devices, Archos, Common Audio, Supported Portable Devices.

    Editing funcionts like trim and crop DVD/ Blu-Ray clips, customize profile list and different watermarks?

  37. Avatar
    adikshoes 12 months later:

    This article gives the light in which we can observe the reality. This is very nice one and gives in-depth information.

  38. Avatar
    nikejordanair 12 months later:

    The blog is really appreaciable and i like to keep on visiting this site once again that it would help me in further thanks for sharing the info.

  39. Avatar
    newairjordanhunt 12 months later:

    Thank you for the information I agree with you I became fan of you and would love to visit your blog regularly.

  40. Avatar
    women hoodies 12 months later:

    I am not a CSM myself, and have no intention of joining their ranks.It’s hard to guess what will happen in the futrue.

  41. Avatar
    ardike 12 months later:

    I’m not understand this article very well…I’d like to share something new with you here.

  42. Avatar
    newwomeninjeans 12 months later:

    Great article though so thanks it’s very interesting you did lot of research before posting any new content.

  43. Avatar
    nhl-nfljerseys 12 months later:

    I don’t have anything else to include on to your article – you basically spelled everything out. great read.

  44. Avatar
    newnikesbdunks 12 months later:

    I would like to thank you for this post. I recently come across your blog and was reading along.

  45. Avatar
    nikedunkhighs 12 months later:

    Thank you for sharing, my families and I all like you article ,reading you article is our best love.

  46. Avatar
    picknikeairmax 12 months later:

    There are some very great sources here and thank you for being so kind to post them here. So we can read them and give our opinion on subject.

  47. Avatar
    Samsung UN40C7000 about 1 year later:

    Nice, thank for the article about The CSM Integrity Deficit

  48. Avatar
    Bucarest Appartamenti about 1 year later:

    I think we found something to agree on with this whole certification thing wrt to the Scrum Alliance. This CSD sounds like a how technical people might solve a business problem of how do we find quality software developers.

    It also feels like a way to help CST make money now that all the potential (?) training candidates have CSM. I have a fear we will have a bunch of CST who don’t actually do Scrum, just teach about it. There is big difference about teaching this stuff and doing it. Bucarest Appartamenti

  49. Avatar
    Tenant Screening about 1 year later:

    This is such a good information. Thanks for sharing this to us.

  50. Avatar
    Hosting about 1 year later:

    Wide range of web hosting services are accessible, such as cheap vps , email hosting, Unix hosting, forex vps , Windows hosting, Linux web hosting windows vps etc. We hope you will find a cheap hosting company.

  51. Avatar
    residential drug and alcohol treatment about 1 year later:

    What a blogpost!! Very informative and easy to understand. Looking for more such blogposts!!

  52. Avatar
    residential drug and alcohol treatment about 1 year later:

    Very informative and easy to understand. Looking for more such blogposts!!

  53. Avatar
    Designer Bags about 1 year later:

    Good topic.Thanks for sharing! It really helpful to me about those information..

  54. Avatar
    Electronic Book Readers about 1 year later:

    Your web site is absolutely full of remarkable info and facts as well as is actually incredibly enjoyable to learn through.Properly performed:)

  55. Avatar
    Pandora about 1 year later:

    I suppose the students who take our TDD course could claim to be Object Mentor Certified TDDers; and they’d be right.

  56. Avatar
    Apartments for rent Bucharest about 1 year later:

    Having personally suffered for six years under a dysfunctional corporate development environment, I feel, on the one hand, that ANY degree of progress toward agile would have been a huge improvement and, if a “CSM” badge helps convince management to make the necessary changes, then I’m all for it

  57. Avatar
    ?????????? mp3 ??????? ????????? about 1 year later:

    Great stuff, worth reading. Thanks for sharing!

  58. Avatar
    eating disorder counsellor harley street about 1 year later:

    Nice article.. it greatly helped me . thanks for this post.

  59. Avatar
    alcohol detox treatment about 1 year later:

    I found your blog when I was looking for a different sort of information but I was very happy and glad to read through your blog. The information available here is great.

  60. Avatar
    http://www.blacktowhiteiphone4.com about 1 year later:

    Enjoy the christmas time and enjoy the hottest white iphone 4. All you need to do is the white iphone 4 conversion kit home.

  61. Avatar
    Silicone Molding about 1 year later:

    Mold making is the core business of Intertech (Taiwan). With world level technology, Intertech enjoys a very good reputation for making Injection Mold and Plastic Moldsfor their worldwide customers.

  62. Avatar
    Harrishcolin about 1 year later:

    Wow! what an idea ! What a concept ! Beautiful my blogs: cityville cheats | cityville tips

  63. Avatar
    Criminal Check about 1 year later:

    Great stuff, worth reading. Thanks for this awesome information.

  64. Avatar
    wastewater treatment about 1 year later:

    CMS has now reduce the labor of web design.Many people are now involved in it and make our web life easier and faster.It is now integrated with the many web-server Platform. Joomla, Wordpress, LiveJournal are great CMS for use.

  65. Avatar
    dolce & gabbana perfume about 1 year later:

    This CSD sounds like a how technical people might solve a business problem of how do we find quality software developers.

  66. Avatar
    iPad ePub Transfer for Mac about 1 year later:

    I really like this essay. Thank you for writing it so seriously. I want to recommend it for my friends strongly. iPad ePub Transfer for Mac is a Professional transfer that can transfer the ePub books onto your iPad on Mac and export the iPad ePub to Mac local folder.

  67. Avatar
    iPad to mac transfer about 1 year later:

    Thanks for shareing! I agree with you. The artical improve me so much! I will come here frequently. iPad to Mac Transfer lets you transfer music, movie, photo, ePub, PDF, Audiobook, Podcast and TV Show from iPad to Mac or iPad to iTunes.

  68. Avatar
    Leeds escort agency about 1 year later:

    Well put. An open and objective view if ever I heard one. Might be nice if everyonein the community was able to express themsleves as clearly.

  69. Avatar
    Discount NBA Jerseys about 1 year later:

    Going to play with it, right away. Will post updates. Cool bit.

  70. Avatar
    Hoteluri Bucuresti about 1 year later:

    To me, it is not much different from a company insisting on a college degree to do work where years of experience has probably prepared a person better for such work.

  71. Avatar
    Criminal Records about 1 year later:

    If you’ve been around this place long enough, and read some of the comments of TDD practitioners you’d know that not all “are of one mind” either.

  72. Avatar
    iPhone SMS to Mac Backup about 1 year later:

    Would you like to banckup iphone SMS to mac, macBook, macbookPro as .txt files? Now a software iphone SMS to Mac Backup can help you to realize it.

  73. Avatar
    taxcreditscalculator about 1 year later:

    Design.Many Web CMS is now, and our lives easier and more Web faster.It Web has reduced the people involved in working with integrated server platform. The Joomla system, WordPress, LiveJournal, CMS uses a good thing.

  74. Avatar
    Sunglass about 1 year later:

    Inspired ,MEN designer Sunglasses Women Replica Sunglass at cheap discount price

  75. Avatar
    dory about 1 year later:

    This was a really fantastic post that I really do appreciate. This is something that is really amazing and interesting to me to say the least. Social Network

  76. Avatar
    Disney On Ice Chicago about 1 year later:

    Thanks for the bunch of good resourceful site.I really appreciate your blog,you have done the great job.hey your blog design is very nice, clean and fresh and with updated content, make people feel peace and I always like browsing your site.Disney On Ice Chicago

  77. Avatar
    Sarah about 1 year later:

    I agree. I do not believe there is an any kind of “integrity debt” when it comes to CSM certification.

    Sarah likes TurboTax Free

  78. Avatar
    bird houses for sale about 1 year later:

    Good stuff you have here, I was going to mention this to a good friend of mine bird houses for sale

  79. Avatar
    saint petersburg hotels about 1 year later:

    thanks a lot for providing this information. thanks

  80. Avatar
    okey oyunu oyna about 1 year later:

    Yes thanks so much…

    internette görüntülü olarak okey oyunu oyna, gerçek kisilerle tanis, turnuva heyecanini yasa.

  81. Avatar
    dallmeier electronic about 1 year later:

    I agree with the above info that CSM system detect deficit error and above info is bit healthy and this is quite effective info dallmeier

  82. Avatar
    mts converter about 1 year later:

    Here MTS Converter can easily Convert MTS files to popular formats like MTS to AVI Converter, <a href=”http://www.convertmts.com/convert_mts_to_dvd.html”>MTS to DVD Converter , supports convert MTS to MP4, and convert mts to mp4, Moreover, you can try MTS to mov Converter to convert MTS to WMV and Edit MTS files, like join mts, cut mts, free download avchd converter now! supports <a href=”http://www.convertmts.com/mts_converter_for_mac.html”>MTS Converter Mac !

  83. Avatar
    Josieklein07 about 1 year later:

    I am not a big fan of this but i am interesting to know about the this.i have to read some issues those are too much critical to i like to know about this its an interesting topic. marble richmond

  84. Avatar
    hair stylist about 1 year later:

    Waoo, your article point of view of this passage is quite correct, the details of yours is very reasonable and you give us valuable information booth, I totally agree with the view of the stage.

  85. Avatar
    Best Phone Lookup about 1 year later:

    I visited this page first time and found it Very Good Job of acknowledgment and a marvelous source of info…......Thanks Admin!

  86. Avatar
    Jewellery about 1 year later:

    Online UK costume and fashion jewellery shop with,

  87. Avatar
    beats by dr dre headphones about 1 year later:

    I attempted these Beats by dr dre studio out in several genres thinking about which i listen to an eclectic mix Beats by dr dre solo. A all natural suit With Solos, you really feel the music, not the Monster Beats By Dr. Dre Pro Headphones Black.

  88. Avatar
    bunker gear about 1 year later:

    o the extent a hiring manager could reasonably perceive bunker gear

  89. Avatar
    christian louboutin shoes on sale about 1 year later:

    What a wonderful article!

  90. Avatar
    cheap ray ban sunglasses about 1 year later:

    Weekend ago, I purchased this ray ban online here. Today, I come here to select another cheap ray ban sunglasses for my son. I am fond of good sunglasses for the charm I bought here.

  91. Avatar
    Excellent Post! about 1 year later:

    Scott Ambler is really a good writer.I see his many blogs.Dirty dealings and desperate is really a great topic to discus.Thanks for sharing such a type of information with us. site analytics

  92. Avatar
    reizen naar india about 1 year later:

    When it comes to certification of any kind, I can not agree with the proposal to grant Heinlein every Californian a college diploma – as he said, costs nothing and does no harm to anyone. It’s not like the “real” diplomas mean nothing.

  93. Avatar
    reizen naar india about 1 year later:

    When it comes to certification of any kind, I can not agree with the proposal to grant Heinlein every Californian a college diploma – as he said, costs nothing and does no harm to anyone. It’s not like the “real” diplomas mean nothing.

  94. Avatar
    reizen naar india about 1 year later:

    When it comes to certification of any kind, I can not agree with the proposal to grant Heinlein every Californian a college diploma – as he said, costs nothing and does no harm to anyone. It’s not like the “real” diplomas mean nothing.

  95. Avatar
    free ad post about 1 year later:

    Simply good posting :)

  96. Avatar
    Betty Wilkinson about 1 year later:

    Good article more useful to me, I will continue to pay attention, and I love discount evening wedding dress,I hope you lot just my site! discount aline wedding dresses http://www.tofuchina.com

  97. Avatar
    Tory Burch outlet online about 1 year later:

    Thanks for the useful information, I really like it and think it’s a good info..

  98. Avatar
    gucci belts over 2 years later:

    Good post.You did a good work and offer more effective imformation for us

    href=”http://www.cheapguccibeltsformen.com/”>gucci belts for men

    .Thank you.

    href=”http://www.cheapguccibeltsformen.com/”>cheap gucci belt

    .

  99. Avatar
    retail traffic counting over 2 years later:

    this is so informative and nice comment. i would to says for all this information. its really amazing.

  100. Avatar
    UGG Mayfaire over 2 years later:

    I’m really happy I found it thank you very much

  101. Avatar
    moleskin over 2 years later:

    These kind of post are always inspiring and I prefer to check out quality content so I happy to find many good point here in the post, writing is simply great, thank you for the post.

  102. Avatar
    MTS Convertisseur over 2 years later:

    Swing open the door, and behold a tableau that perfectly captures the tween aesthetic. The polka-dot chandelier. The zebra-print wallpaper. The lime green shag rug that pulls the look together — without being too matchy-matchy, as a pre-tween might have it. MTS Convertisseur But you can’t go in because the door doesn’t lead to a room. It leads to a locker. Specifically, Nola Storey’s locker at Rye Middle School in a New York suburb. MTS Convertisseur Mac

  103. Avatar
    Ashley Bowling over 2 years later:

    A leopard cannot change its spots

  104. Avatar
    ysbearing/yisong@1stbearing.com over 2 years later:

    Slewing bearing called slewing ring bearings, is a comprehensive load to bear a large bearing, can bear large axial, radial load and overturning moment. http://www.1stbearing.com

  105. Avatar
    Tissot Lady Classic Watches over 2 years later:

    vintage tissot ladies is your best choice to wear Tissot T-Touch is very atmospheric, but also very stylish, Tissot T-Touch Expert, the design is very innovative, I believe that you will put it down.

  106. Avatar
    christian louboutin over 2 years later:

    The professional design make you foot more comfortable. Even more tantalizing,this pattern make your legs look as long as you can,it will make you looked more attractive.Moveover,it has reasonable price.If you are a popular woman,do not miss it.

    Technical details of Christian Louboutin Velours Scrunch Suede Boots Coffee:

    Color: Coffee
    Material: Suede
    4(100mm) heel
    Signature red sole x

    Fashion, delicate, luxurious Christian louboutins shoes on sale, one of its series is Christian Louboutin Tall Boots, is urbanism collocation. This Christian louboutins shoes design makes people new and refreshing. Red soles shoes is personality, your charm will be wonderful performance.

  107. Avatar
    Dr.Dre Casque over 2 years later:

    They actual beats through Beats de Dr.Dre Solo HD Graphiteprovide a classy and cozy pattern also as extraordinarily crispy sound reactionbeats by dre Solo Noir. beats by dre Solo pourpretop of the range related to audio is balanced, in conjunction with snug mids and conjointly walloping striped bassbeats by dre Studio Pourpre. Beats By Dre Studio PinkProvided completely are a nice travel case also as a brand new music-telephone-compatible cableBeats By Dre Studio Michael Jackson. the actual Beast Conquer headphones couldn’t be taken devoid of battery powerBeats By Dre Studio Yellow. Beats By Dre Studio All RedPolished African yank style and elegance is quite smudge-prone,beats by dre Pro Blanco and a few songs sound unpleasant. Right dr dre headphones rattles whereas you go. beats by dre Studio MoradosYou’re initial and trendy Huge Surpasses by means of Medical skilled. Dre earphones turn out stable sound, helpful add-ons, and conjointly a look that is not at all imitator.beats by dre LeBron James pro mate relating to fashion-frontward folks that have make the most acquire in order that you’ll spare,beats by dre Studio Blanco they’re fantastic alternative.

  108. Avatar
    hospital curtains over 2 years later:

    This is a really good read for me. Must agree that you are one of the coolest blogger I ever saw. Thanks for posting this useful information. This was just what I was on looking for. I’ll come back to this blog for sure! I bookmarked this blog a while ago because of the useful content and I am never being disappointed. Keep up the good work.

  109. Avatar
    Gold Price over 2 years later:

    Today,American markets are improving.Their economic position is growing.Golden prices make comfort our lives. Gold Price

  110. Avatar
    Polo Ralph Lauren Pas Cher over 2 years later:

    Hi, Brilliant, just I have learnt, what I needed to know. thank you for writing such an excellent article.Please keep it up.

  111. Avatar
    Fitness Training Programs over 2 years later:

    This site is really appreciated..Thanks for sharing this site with us..!

  112. Avatar
    Betty over 2 years later:

    Thanks for offering information. www.LikeJerseys.org . Recently I found a cheaper jerseys website,here have many NFL,NHL,MLB ,NBA and custom jerseys.All jerseys name and number are stitched and with cheap price. Welcome to www.LikeJerseys.org .

  113. Avatar
    lipozene over 2 years later:

    This site is really appreciated..Thanks for sharing this site with us..!

  114. Avatar
    clarkreed over 3 years later:

    Thanks for the information, I’ll visit the site again to get update information video games

  115. Avatar
    jerseyshome over 3 years later:

    Welcome to visit our website: http://www.jerseyshome.net/. We offer jerseys ?headphones?caps and so on . and Denver Broncos 18 Peyton Manning jerseys are available. More than 10 items, we offer free shipping. And we will also give you a 10% discount when you pay by western union.

  116. Avatar
    bladeless fans over 3 years later:

    The CSM Integrity Deficit 115 good post96

  117. Avatar
    louboutin sales over 3 years later:

    The CSM Integrity Deficit 116 hoo,good article!!I like the post!172

  118. Avatar
    picnic catering philadelphia over 3 years later:

    o how true this is certs dont mean crap today. yes they mean something to corporate but not to anyone else

  119. Avatar
    http://couponchip.com/coupon-codes/ over 3 years later:

    Encountered this blog for the first time and it impressed me so much.

  120. Avatar
    Injection mold over 3 years later:

    Intertech Machinery Inc. provides the most precise Plastic Injection Mold and Rubber Molds from Taiwan. With applying excellent unscrewing device in molds,

    Intertech is also very professional for making flip top Cap Molds in the world. Mold making is the core business of Intertech (Taiwan). With world level technology, Intertech enjoys a very good reputation for making Injection Mold and Plastic Molds for their worldwide customers.

  121. Avatar
    luxury hermes birkin bag over 3 years later:

    You know it’s time to update a room, but the idea of actually doing it fills you with dread?

  122. Avatar
    Injetion Mold over 3 years later:

    With more than 20 years of experience, Intertech provides an extensive integrated operational ability from design to production of molds 100% made in Taiwan. Additional to our own mold making factory, we also cooperate with our team vendors to form a very strong working force in Taiwan.

    For the overseas market, we work very closely with local representatives in order to take care of the technical communication and after-sales service to our customers. We also participate in the EUROMOLD & FAKUMA exhibitions and meet our customers every year in Europe. By concentrating on mold “niche markets”, we play a very useful mold maker role from the Far East whenever customers want to develop their new projects. We provide services from A to Z to our customers on a very economic cost and effect basis.

  123. Avatar
    girl cosplay over 3 years later:

    http://www.outfitscosplay.com/cosplay-catalog/xxxholic-cosplay Deluxe xxxHolic Cosplay Costumes for Sale.Find your favorite characters and cosplay outfits from all the popular anime and games.

  124. Avatar
    shop cosplay over 3 years later:

    http://www.outfitscosplay.com/cosplay-catalog/yu-gi-oh-cosplay Deluxe Yu-Gi-Oh! Cosplay Costumes for Sale.Find your favorite characters and cosplay outfits from all the popular anime and games.

  125. Avatar
    cosplay 2012 over 3 years later:

    http://www.outfitscosplay.com/cosplay-wigs Deluxe Cosplay Wigs for Sale.Find your favorite characters and cosplay outfits from all the popular anime and games.

  126. Avatar
    li wo over 3 years later:

    beats by dre headphone vivienne westwood Melissa chirstian louboutin sale michael kors outlet store vivienne westwood handbags

    michael kors outlet storeThe newly elected President of Egypt Morsy muhammad published the first speech since his victory over ahmed ShaFei g announced on Sunday night, vowed to “protect the international agreement and obligations”, this seems to be a reference of the peace treaty with Israel..chirstian louboutin outlet

    vivienne westwood melissa Morsy tried to appease those worried that he will take immediate action to change the whole Egypt, is expected to become the President all the egyptians, “muslims, christians, old people, children, women and men, farmers, teachers, workers, those engaged in the private and public sectors, the businessmen.”beats by dre headphone

    michael kors clearance bags Morsy welcome Obama’s support, the two leaders reaffirm their dedicated to advancing US-Egypt partnership, agreed to maintain close contact with the future of a few weeks, months, according to the statement. Christian Louboutin Daffodile 160mm Pumps

  127. Avatar
    swarovski for sale over 3 years later:

    You may think what a hair straightener can do with the curling process, swarovski for sale but actually a hair straightener can also perform the curling process swarovski online so that its task is not just confined to straightening the hair. arm bangle People who are unaware of the basics of styling with a hot styling swarovski crystal hearts tool may think that they need a separate straightening and curling iron for the different processes of styling.

Comments