Slim 45
Those of you who have been following me on Twitter have heard me talk about Slim. Slim is a new testing front-end and back-end that I’m adding to FitNesse. Here’s what it’s all about.
FitNesse is a very popular open-source acceptance testing tool that allows non-programmers to write and execute tests. FitNesse is an authoring and execution wrapper around the testing engine Fit. Fit interprets HTML and uses a set of programmer supplied fixtures to invoke the system under test.
The problem is that Fit is big. There’s a lot of stuff inside there. And it all has to be ported to the language (or platform) of the system under test (SUT). Unfortunately, since Fit is all open source it means that the various ports don’t agree with each other. It also means that a change made to one, does not match a change made to another. This is deeply frustrating.
To make matters worse, the effort required to maintain a fit port is relatively high. The folks who maintain these ports do so out of the goodness of their own hears, and have real jobs that often take effort away from Fit.
The end result is that the universe of Fit is uneven at best. Java programmers can use one set of features and fixtures, whereas C++ programmers must use a completely different set. The .NET version of the fixtures work in a very different way from the Java versions. New languages and platforms require a relatively large effort just to get started with Fit. etc.
Slim—The solution
Fit interprets HTML tables in order to make specific calls to the SUT. Fit does all this interpetation in the SUT. What if we moved all that table interpretation to FitNesse? FitNesse is written in Java and communicates with the SUT through a socket. Right now it passes all the HTML through that socket to Fit and accepts the colorized HTML back through the socket from Fit. But what if we changed the partitioning? What if we did all the table processing in FitNesse and then shipped a list of calls across the socket to the SUT?
That’s what Slim is. Slim is a very small module that runs in the SUT. It listens at a socket for very simple commands that instruct it to create instances of fixtures and to call methods on those instances. It passes the return values of those method calls back through the socket.
Slim is very small. Porting it is a matter of a few hours work. Once ported, there’s virtually no other maintenance required. It seems unlikely that new Slim features will be needed very often.
What this means is that all the table processing is done on the FitNesse side, and will work exactly the same regardless of the platform of the SUT. C++, Ruby, Java, Python, C#? It doesn’t matter, your tables will work in exactly the same way.
And who said we needed tables anyway? Since all the processing is done on the FitNesse side, we can write new kinds of testing languages. We can write story runners like RSpec or JBehave. They will all use Slim to communicate to the SUT, and will all work identically with any platform that has a Slim port.
Slim Tables
If you are familiar with Fit, you know that there are different fixture types. There are ColumnFixtures, RowFixtures, ActionFixtures, DoFixtures, etc. Each of these require a library to be written and executed on the SUT.
In Slim we replace these with processors on the FitNesse side. Instead of ColumnFixtures we have DecisionTables. Instead of RowFixtures we have QueryTables. Instead of DoFixtures we have ScriptTables. New kinds of tables can be added using a simple plug-in mechanism.
Slim Fixtures
Slim fixtures are very similar to Fit Fixtures except that they don’t inherit from anything! There is no library on the SUT that you have to include.
Interestingly enough, if you already have a Fit ColumnFixture written for your SUT, it will very likely work with a Slim DecisionTable. Existing RowFixtures will likely work nicely with a Slim QueryTable, etc.
Migrating to Slim
To replace Fit with Slim for a test page, all you need to do is set the variable TEST_SYSTEM to slim. This will invoke the Slim table processor rather than the old Fit test runner.
!define TEST_SYSTEM {slim}
There are some minor differences in the table format. The biggest is that the table type is no longer known by the fixture. Therefore FitNesse needs to know what kind of table you are writing. So a column fixture that used to look like this:
|eg.Division|
|numerator|denominator|quotient|
|10 |2 |5 |
|DT:eg.Division|
|numerator|denominator|quotient|
|10 |2 |5 |
Did you see the DT:? That’s it. Otherwise the tables should be the same. And as you might guess there will be similar prefixes for QueryTable (QT), and ScriptTable (ST).
Indeed, this is the part of the Slim Tables that I like the least. If anybody has a better idea, or at least some better prefixes, I’m all ears (er. eyes).
((Update: For Decision Tables the “DT:” is not necessary but can be supplied. Or you can use the prefix “Decision:” (See FitNesse User Guide for more details). For Query tables the prefix is “Query:”, For Script tables the first cell is just the word “Script”))
What if you like processing tables in fixtures?
Some of you might use TableFixture, or just do your own table processing in your Fit fixtures. You can still do that with Slim. One of the table types I plan to implement is a raw Table (Table prefix). The whole table gets shipped over the socket to the fixtures as a List of Lists of Strings, and the fixture returns with a table with the same geometry, loaded with “pass”, “fail”, or “neutral” to provide colorization hints.
Current Status.
I currently have Slim working in Java, and Decision Tables being processed. What I don’t have so far are any of the other table types, suites, command line test runners, etc. So there’s plenty of work to be done.
This sounds good. I just want to clarify, all our same tests will still work with adding a prefix to the fixture name, for example – our DoFixture tests will still work, we just have to add ‘ST’ in front of the fixture name?
Lisa, there are some differences between the way the slim tables work and the way that fit tables work. For example, to use DecisionTables with a ColumnFixture you will have to add setXXX functions since Slim can only call functions and cannot load variables. The tables themselves will likely need little or no change.
To avoid the funny table type prefix, send a request to the SUT asking it for the table type. In your division example above, you presumably send a command to instantiate eg.Division. Then send a command to execute getTableType on the instance.
I’ve been looking for a FitNesse/FitLibrary solution for Ruby and this sounds promising.
One thing that I would like to see (not sure if this can be Slim’s responsibility or not) is a way to tag tests like gmail or del.icio.us tagging works.
I’ll be looking forward to cutting some tests over to try out Slim when it’s ready.
@Tim – you might want to check out cucumber if you’re using ruby.
Hi, you write that you got it working for Java. So the next thing to do would be to port the Slim back-end into another language. You said that it should be done very quickly. Can you explain how to port it to C++? Thanks
Hi I’m wondering if you guys tried to use the dt in a vertical format. Something like this, http://3.bp.blogspot.com/_KukQ8TlQMz8/Sa4VMujoG7I/AAAAAAAAAcw/KvCWqhjC29w/s1600-h/Picture+2.png
My object that I want to test has a big list of attributes and I want to create a scenarios based on those attributes but the table end up so wide. It would be nice if we can laid it out in a vertical format.
Any help or suggestion will be appreciated.
Thanks
Do we have SLIM port for perl available?
I’ll be looking forward to cutting some tests over to try out Slim when it’s ready…
I just want to clarify, all our same tests will still work with adding a prefix to the fixture name, for example – our tests will still work…
One thing that I would like to see (not sure if this can be Slim’s responsibility or not) is a way to tag tests like gmail or del.icio.us tagging works.
me gusta mucho!
One thing that I would like to see (not sure if this can be Slim’s responsibility or not) is a way to tag tests like gmail or del.icio.us tagging works.
www.chinawonderfultour.com
CDKeyforsale.com sells most popular game cd keys. Such as: Diablo 2 CD Key, Warcraft 3 CD Key, Starcraft CD Key.
http://www.bingobonusonline.com
This is a great site, very handy, just what i was looking for, keep up the good work, many thanks!....best business offer
The man with a new http://www.handbags4buy.com/ idea is a crank until the idea succeeds.
Thank you for another informative post! I appreciate your efforts. Online Shopping Sites
Very quietly I take my leave.To seek a dream in http://www.edhardy-buy.com/ starlight.
hey….. good to see u again…another nice posting..thanx Data entry services in pune
come to have a look
Its really very Interesting article and really had me thinking will make sure I check your posts more often! It contains a useful information in it..Thanks, list of packers and movers
FitNesse is a very good code. We are very grateful to share this technology, I will go test it
I was robbed on craigslist by some lowlife hiding behind a mobile line. Asswipe was speechless when I got her addy info and came calling lol!
i like wearing ed hardy clothes. do you?
Good post and easy read. You have raised some valid points. Great work, keep it up. I love returning back to this site and reading the quality content you always have on offer.
It is really interesting and beautiful,what you have said and described is just what I am dreaming for,I am happy to see this.
lso unsurprising was the http://www.sunglasses1987.com wholesale sunglasses schadenfreude emanating from Ireland.
i like wearing ed hardy clothes. do you?
Good post and easy read. You have raised some valid points. Great work, keep it up. I love returning back to this site and reading the quality content you always have on offer.
I have read your article for a several times and I was impressed by it! It was very interesting so I shared it with my friends. Hope they will like it too. The Adjustment Bureau watch online
I totally love this article. I think you could write some other things to make your blog more complete The ebagseller
Summer is very hot, who can wear article 7 minutes of [url=http://www.lydress.com] pants[/url], must the cowboy oh, the best side or a small beads embroidery that paillette, or color, the best is shallow blue, body parts, the condole belt unlined upper [url=http://www.ququgofashion.com]garments [/url] grows out of a piece of short sweater, small hollow-out sweater is better, there is colour with cream-colored, white, give priority to, in a few pieces of bright, very pretty, tie-in use: oh!!!!!!!!!!!
Summer is very hot, who can wear article 7 minutes of http://www.lydress.com> pants, must the cowboy oh, the best side or a small beads embroidery that paillette, or color, the best is shallow blue, body parts, the condole belt unlined upper http://www.ququgofashion.com>garments grows out of a piece of short sweater, small hollow-out sweater is better, there is colour with cream-colored, white, give priority to, in a few pieces of bright, very pretty, tie-in use: oh!!!!!!!!!!!
Romance is out of summer, the perfect period. Outing Romantic, melting snow spins dress is today season vogue girls wear build up the important sheet is tasted, using qualitative produce elegant light spins the romantic sense, plus the broken this year popular element , presents different female glamour. The frivolous fabrics spins or cultivate one’s morality is best, clear and elegant texture to help you hide fat shape, block butterfly arm.
In this summer, the romantic and small, is confronted dragon-boat festival holiday for a picnic superexcellent period. Romantic, melting snow spins http://www.ququgofashion.com>dress is today season vogue girls wear build up the important sheet is tasted, using qualitative produce elegant light spins the romantic sense, plus the broken this year http://www.lydress.com> popular element , presents different female glamour.
Romance is out of summer, the perfect period. Outing Romantic, melting snow spins dress is today season vogue girls wear build up the important sheet is tasted, using qualitative produce elegant light spins the romantic sense, plus the broken this year popular element , presents different female glamour. The frivolous fabrics spins or cultivate one’s morality is best, clear and elegant texture to help you hide fat shape, block butterfly arm.
Three blonde women were stranded on an island. While trying to dig their way out, one of them came across a buried lamp. Suddenly a genie appears and offers to grant each one of them one wish, in return for saving him.
Cowherd skirtis hot girl never refuse, voted into the gradual change effect of hot pantsto make you look more special, flanging style collocation with wrinkles around pocket design, add brown belts, and in a few ornament before fork, let you sexy metal buckles, feeling restoring ancient ways must try oh, beautiful eyebrow go shopping festival are handsome gas, absolutely super grab an eye.
Sorching summer, is coming. The most comfortable, put a cool and refreshing way, wear a dressout of fashion, wear a comfortable, should be the one summer MMS chasing dreams. Bright colours by all the summer dress up, also can let your mood will no longer dry frowsty upset!
Summer is very hot, who can wear article 7 minutes of pants, must the cowboy oh, the best side or a small beads embroidery that paillette, or color, the best is shallow blue, body parts, the condole belt unlined upper garments grows out of a piece of short sweater, small hollow-out sweater is better, there is colour with cream-colored, white, give priority to, in a few pieces of bright, very pretty, tie-in use: oh!!!!!!!!!!!
,,, I have read your article for a several times and I was impressed by it! It was very interesting so I shared it with my friends. ,,,
cheap VPS have read your article for a several times and I was impressed by it! It was very interesting so I shared it with my friends. ,,,
I really loved it the way of the stuff provided in this article. I definitely enjoying every little bit of it.