Search | Blog | Contact

Why play a scale when you could be playing a tune? 37

Posted by David Chelimsky Fri, 05 Jan 2007 05:21:35 GMT

Many years ago I read an interview with Pat Metheny in which the interviewer asked him about how he approaches practicing scales. This is from memory from a long time ago, so forgive any misquotes (and if anyone can help me find the text of the interview I’ll be glad to update this post), but he responded with something like “Scales are an important part of improvising and there are elements of scales in everything we play. But practicing scales by themselves isn’t that interesting. Why would you want to play a scale when you could be playing a tune?”

I’ve heard other musicians talk about this in terms of “if you practice scales you’ll play scales on the gig”. I believe this to be true, and can be found manifested in the music of many who like to call themselves jazz musicians.

That always resonated with me as an aspiring musician, and has manifested itself within my sensibilities about software as craft. This relates to why I’ve latched on to BDD and the surrounding conversation.

Focusing on internal state and structure in your tests is like practicing scales. The end result is often code that is clean in a vacuum, but doesn’t express its intent well – just like hearing that guitar player running scales up and down (again). It may use the most theoretically efficient techniques, but it fails to tell a story.

Focusing on observable behaviour in your tests is like practicing melodies. The result is that your code is more likely to express its intent. It’s more likely to be just the right code for that particular requirement. Just like the improvisor who always plays exactly the right thing for that moment.

Comments

Leave a response

  1. Avatar
    mnrp 12 days later:

    I always tried to approached practicing (scales, tunes, sonatas, whatever) like I was playing music, so that when I was performing (sonatas, tunes, scales, whatever) I sounded like I was playing music not practicing. Maybe tests are like that: write them to be software not tests.

  2. Avatar
    coachoutlet over 4 years later:
    Today, Coach has developed into a global brand, offers a variety of decorative assembly line of men and women.Our coach outlet include handbags, shoes, watches, outdoor clothing, scarves, sunglasses, jewelry and perfume series coach bags.Welcome to see coach brooke collection .

    http://www.coachoutletnew.com

  3. Avatar
    Marble Games over 4 years later:

    Just wondering – there’s so many good tunes out there. The scale you’ve been assigned is just a series of notes in a certain order or pattern

  4. Avatar
    Rent Apartment Bucharest over 4 years later:

    Good view, it would have been interesting to read the entire interview

  5. Avatar
    autoclave over 4 years later:

    I recently came accross your blog and have been reading along.I thought I would leave my first comment. I dont know what to say except that I have enjoyed reading.Nice blog.I will keep visiting this blog very often.

  6. Avatar
    Big pony over 4 years later:

    It’s a nice article. I would like to share ralph lauren shirt with you.These are from the latest styles and fashion trends shirts.

  7. Avatar
    okey oyunu oyna over 4 years later:

    good paragraph Thanks admin…

    Okey Oyunu Oyna

  8. Avatar
    waxing over 4 years later:

    Hello every one! I recently found your blog and reading along.I I thought I’d leave the first comment. I do not know what to say except that I enjoyed blog.I reading.Nice keep visiting this blog very often.

  9. Avatar
    Feromonas over 4 years later:

    practice practice practice..that’s the way to Carnegie Hall

  10. Avatar
    Lovecam over 5 years later:

    Retrouve des filles coquines qui s’exhibent en camsexy derrière leur webcam.

  11. Avatar
    costo impianti fotovoltaici over 5 years later:

    You live a charmed life and I am glad to know you via the blog! I swear I could hear that fountain as I looked on!

    costo impianti fotovoltaici

    incentivi fotovoltaico

  12. Avatar
    mrsavljenje over 5 years later:

    Considerably, the story is in reality the greatest on this noteworthy topic.

  13. Avatar
    145c ink cartridges over 5 years later:

    I found this site of the best quality containing post. brother ink

  14. Avatar
    bryan over 5 years later:

    Very nice question you have asked. I am thinking for best reply with arguments. lagos flgihts

  15. Avatar
    cheap air shoes over 5 years later:

    While the official Air Jordan 2012 Flight Arrangement (shoe with one sleeve and one cushioning system) drops on Feb. 25,

  16. Avatar
    cheap china jerseys over 5 years later:

    closing out a aural of the best chalk-full-of-releases Wednesdays in beside anamnesis (Air Diamond Turf II here,

  17. Avatar
    inexpensive jerseys over 5 years later:

    Fans all make an effort to have the identical and show their warmly supporting, but what’s terribled them a whole lot could be the costs are really at high level.

  18. Avatar
    cheap snapback hats over 5 years later:

    The animation and recreation style globe is generally a multi-billion greenback business. Also it keeps on to cultivate.

  19. Avatar
    cheap snapback over 5 years later:

    Specialists predict this pattern will proceed for the fantastic years as individuals of any age are a many more and more enthusiastic about this thrilling area.

  20. Avatar
    blank snapback hat over 5 years later:

    For the reason that need for these kinds of solutions is continually growing, you will find numerous job possibilities for anyone those who contain the creativeness as well as the generate that may be forced to succeed.

  21. Avatar
    bestlvreplica over 5 years later:

    In this modern and fashionable society, people are pursuing for sac longchamp cool, unique, stylish and innovative. Whether it is longchamp sac or fashion accessories all means a lot for modern society of today. Same is the case with trendy looking sac à main Longchamp. When these are sac longchamp pliage, the excitement just gets doubled. Most chic looking sac longchamp pas cher are in fashion now. These are one of the favorite fashion accessories for men and women long time ago. If you have not yet tried coach canada, it’s time to own one and feel the difference it can make to your personality. These are just brilliant and fabulous coach outlet canada. They are most iconic and can provide you with a new feeling and enhance confidence. The quality of coach outlet online is just superior to what you have dreamt of. Different styles and designs of coach bags sale are now available to make your wrist beautiful. You can choose from the wide variety of coach handbags by comparing lots of perfect and stunning pieces. These coach outlet store online would be nice investments for you in long term. These coach online outlet store are brilliant and prove to be wonderful for you while it makes you stand out of the crowd

  22. Avatar
    blank snapback hat over 5 years later:

    You can put these on acquire you airing with the basic or already you ball your alleged baseball activity calm calm with your colleagues on the park.

  23. Avatar
    cheap air shoes over 5 years later:

    The best able area to chafe these anteroom the bleachers aback you achieve your admired accord ball abut adapted teams.

  24. Avatar
    cheap china jerseys over 5 years later:

    That doesn’t abject that added layoffs & downsizings usually are not achievable, about for see your face hunting for a chump abutment profession axial the aerodynamics industry, the best appellation has brightened significantly.

  25. Avatar
    inexpensive jerseys over 5 years later:

    It’s possible to go shopping for their most favorite outfit online or clothing stores. The net supplies a wider selection the other may well find among the better discounts out there. Execute research and locate the best selection.

  26. Avatar
    cheap snapback hats over 5 years later:

    The next step is once the player or team has lesser appearances thus, lesser following. Deeply saying, putting on a costume which carry the brand of the preferred league either the title of one’s favored player is a good course to exhibit your adoration.

  27. Avatar
    cheap snapback over 5 years later:

    you may put them under wherever you visit. You can put these on suppose you stroll with the mall or once you play your selected sport together with your colleagues on the park.

  28. Avatar
    blank snapback hat over 5 years later:

    The most effective destination to wear these jerseys reaches the bleachers when you make your favorite league play against different teams.

  29. Avatar
    hermes nyc over 5 years later:

    Now by means of cool and modern design,cheap beats by dr dre Monster Beats By Dr Dre Pro High Performance Professional Headphones Black has become more and more popular among people,<a href=”http://www.cheapmonsterbeatsstore.org/monster-beats-by-drdre-beats-pro-high-performance-professional-black-headphone-p-1.html ”>monster beats by dre pro especially the young.beats pro vs beats studio Monster Beats By Dr Dre Pro High Performance Professional Headphones Black not only can bring you amazing sound but also.

  30. Avatar
    UGGs Outlet Rotterdam@hotmail.com over 5 years later:

    Outlet Rotterdam[/url] first saw her will be this ugly bulky appearance can not understand, and is a boots swept the Eurasian land, and now all over the world have whipped up a pop style, this gust of mainstreamEuropean and American stars are brought

  31. Avatar
    UGGs Outlet Rotterdam@hotmail.com over 5 years later:

    UGGs Outlet Rotterdam first saw her will be this ugly bulky appearance can not understand, and is a boots swept the Eurasian land, and now all over the world have whipped up a pop style, this gust of mainstreamEuropean and American stars are brought

  32. Avatar
    Penny over 5 years later:

    The best pianist of all time, Franz List, spent up to 6 hours per day practising purely scales and other technical exercises. It’s boring, and he himself joked that he would become either a madman or an artist… but it obviously paid off…

  33. Avatar
    franklinmarshallsoldes over 5 years later:

    Franklin Marshall Soldes is a fashion brand of forward thinking, constantly moving their style with each new season. However, the brand never fails to preppy roots, keeping a classic look that is sophisticated and easily associated with franklin marshall femme adaptation of good qualité

  34. Avatar
    Tory Burch over 5 years later:

    Have you ever wished that you could change something about the way that you look? Have you ever Tory Burch wished that you could be thinner, or possibly have a different body shape? Well, it is a fact black clutch handbag that the majority of women say that there is at least one thing that they could change about their wooden wedge shoes appearance. As a matter of fact, there are many different types of shoes that allow for women to drastically alter their appearance.

  35. Avatar
    Jimmy Choo Pumps over 5 years later:

    For many new mothers, the options for swarovski sale items feeding a new born baby are bottle wholesale bangle bracelet or breast feeding. According to the crystal rose brooch medical fraternity, a new born should fashion jewelry wholesale be fed by the mother for a minimum swarovski period of six months. Here, electric breast pumps play an important role.

  36. Avatar
    grupna kupovina over 5 years later:

    Very informative article. Thank you!

  37. Avatar
    http://www.frlunettesdesoleil.com/lunettes-de-soleil-lunettes-de-soleil-oakley-c-2_57.html over 6 years later:

    Great post! Je vais vous abonner bon maintenant wth ma logiciels feedreader!lunette de soleil pas cher

Comments