Object Mentor Blog: The 4-contact points of software development

The 4-contact points of software development

Brett Schuchert — Thu, 19 Aug 2010 22:59:00 -0500

The three laws of TDD are:

Write no production code without a failing test
Write just enough of a test to fail
Write just enough production code to get the test to pass

This list doesn’t include refactoring, which is typically an assumed activity. In fact, some people refer to these rules as “red, green, refactor”. An even older version of this, from the Smalltalk community, is Red, Green, Blue. (Why Blue for refactor? I think someone was thinking RBG for a color space, luckily they didn’t try to use CMYK or LAB!)

In this simple model, there two kinds of code: test & production. There are two kinds of activity: writing & refactoring. Interestingly, at one level it is all code. The thing that distinguishes both sets is intent.

The intent of a test is to demonstrate or maybe specify behavior. The intent of production code is to implement (hopefully) business-relevant functionality.

The intent of writing code is creation. The intent of refactoring code is to change (hopefully improve) its structure without changing its behavior (this is oversimplified but essentially correct).

If you mix those combinations you have the 4-limbs of development:

Writing a test
Writing production code
Refactoring a test
Refactoring production code

An important behavior to practice is doing only one of these at a time. That is, when you are writing tests, don’t also write production code. Sure, you might use tools to stub out missing methods and classes, but the heart of what you are doing is writing a test. Finish that train of thought before focusing on writing production code.

On the other hand, if you are refactoring production code, do just that. Don’t change tests at the same time, try to only do one refactoring at a time, etc.

WHY?

First an analogy that almost always misses since most developers don’t additionally rock climb.

When rock climbing, a good general bit of advice is to only move one contact point at a time. For this discussion, consider your two hands and two feet as your four contact points. Sure, you can use your face or knee, but neither are much fun. So just considering two hands and two feet, that suggests that if, for example, you move your right hand, then leave your left hand and both feet in place.

This gives you stability, a chance to easily recover by simply moving the most recent appendage back in place and, when the inevitable happens, another appendage slips, you have a better chance of not eating rock face. If you move more than one thing at a time, you are in more danger because you’ve taken a risky action and reduced the number of points of contact, or stability.

Will you sometimes move multiple appendages? Sure. But not as a habit. Sometimes you need to take risks. The rock face may not always offer up movement patterns that make applying this recommendation possible. Since you know the environment will occasionally work against you, you need to maintain some slack for the inevitable.

Practicing Test Driven Development is similar. If you change production code and tests at the same time, what happens if a test fails? What is wrong? The production code, the test, both, neither? An even more subtle problem is that tests pass but the test is fragile or heavily implementation-dependent. While not necessarily an immediate threat, it represents design debt that will eventually cause problems. (This also happens frequently when tests are written after the production code as it’s seductively easy to write tests that exercise code, expressing the production’s code implementation but fundamentally hiding the intent.)

Notice, if you had only refactored code, then you know the problem is in one place. When you change both, the problem space actually goes from 1 to 3 (4 if you allow for neither). Furthermore, if you are changing both production and test code at the same time and you get to a point where you’ve entered a bottomless pit, you’ll end up throwing away more work if you choose to restore from the repository.

Are there going to be times when you change both? Sure. Sometimes you may not see a clear path that gives you the option to do only one thing at a given time. Sometimes the tests and code will work against you. Often, you’ll be working in a legacy code base where there are no tests. Given that the environment will occasionally (or frequently) work against you, you need to maintain some slack.

Essentially, be focused on a single goal at any given time: write a test. then get it to pass. clean up production code & keep the tests first unchanging and then passing.

I find that this is a hard thing both to learn and to apply. I frequently jump ahead of myself. Unfortunately I’m “lucky” enough when I do jump ahead that when I fail, I thoroughly fall flat on my face.

This approach is contextual (aren’t they all?). Every time you start working on code, you’ll be faced with these four possibilities. Each time you are, you need to figure out what is the most important thing in the moment, and do that one thing. Once you’ve taken care of the most important thing, you may have just promoted the second most important thing to first place. Even so, reassess. What is the most important thing now? Do that.

Good luck trying to apply this idea to your development work. I’m interesting in hearing about it.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by wholesale nike shox

Tue, 07 Feb 2012 00:08:57 -0600

Do not , for one repulse , give up theWholesale nike shoxthat you resolved to effect .

"The 4-contact points of software development" by online docs

Tue, 17 Jan 2012 02:59:30 -0600

it was so interesting….u must keep it up.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Backup iPhone SMS

Sat, 14 Jan 2012 06:37:56 -0600

All software developer should remember the key point of programming.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Chicago construction company

Thu, 12 Jan 2012 07:44:21 -0600

2-I think this is among the most vital info for me. And i am glad reading your article. But should remark on some general things, The site style is ideal, the articles is really great : D. Good job, cheers Chicago construction company

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Chicago construction company

Thu, 12 Jan 2012 07:42:35 -0600

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Chicago construction company

Thu, 12 Jan 2012 07:41:07 -0600

"The 4-contact points of software development" by jordan heels women

Tue, 10 Jan 2012 02:06:29 -0600

More and more people are now engaging into women jordan heels camping especially now that the metros are becoming more and more polluted and congested. Before, this activity has only been a means of adventure and chilling; but now camping has also turned into a popular sport.A usual camping activity starts with the preparation of gears and gadgets. Food are then packed and sealed. After several miles of travel, campers arrive at the Nike heels site. After setting the tents, everyone goes on with different activities: mountain hiking, skiing, snow boarding, etc.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by online shopping

Mon, 09 Jan 2012 01:13:16 -0600

Online shopping in India – Buy top fashion brands online for men and women. Buy footwear, shoes, watches, sunglasses, accessories and cosmetics for men and women at shopatmajorbrands.com

"The 4-contact points of software development" by nikeheelswomen

Fri, 30 Dec 2011 02:22:21 -0600

One of the most famous and widely-practiced dance women jordan heels form is ballet. Almost everyone around the globe knows what ballet is, regardless of whether you are into the art, know someone women jordan heels practicing ballet, have seen it on television or movies, in musical plays or stage presentations. Ballet is the predominant dance art that has enjoyed global appeal.Of all the dance arts Jordan Heels For Women or forms that are being practiced, aside from the territorial or regional ethnic dance forms- ballet enjoys a reputation a notch above the rest since it is associated with prestige and sophistication.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Buy Bag Online Shop

Thu, 29 Dec 2011 22:44:56 -0600

Buy Bag Online Shop change every season so there is something new that comes up all the time for people to pick up. It is a great idea to pick up bags from online stores since they have the best of products and you can avail them easily without any hassles.Online stores have Buy Bag Online as well and a large number of designers showcase their brands on these stores due to the number of people purchasing from these stores. Bag Online Shop You can see the different options available and pick up something that suits you best. It is extremely beneficial to buy Cheapest Bag Online from online stores since it saves a lot of money due to the huge discount offers that these stores have throughout the year.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Best Oakley Sunglasses

Thu, 29 Dec 2011 22:43:19 -0600

Fourth,Best Oakley Sunglasses the lens should be even, through a higher degree of clarity, sunglasses with glass and resin materials, and the best sunglasses polarized lenses should be used. It uses the same lightweight precision and contact lenses made of synthetic resin, synthesized by the seven slices, two layers is the outermost layer of superhard wear; Sunglasses Online Shop second, six are shatter-resistant hardened layer; third, five is the UV filter layer, the middle wholesale Armani Sunglasses layer is the most polarizing filter layer. Polarized lenses can effectively filter out harmful ultraviolet light reflection and have to avoid breakage, wear and other functions, is the most popular sunglasses.Fifth, the sunglasses in addition according to their skin color, face, dressed to match, but should also be based out Sunglasses Cheap of place to choose. In general, black, brown, gray filter works well; gray lenses can be balanced against any absorption chromatography, after wearing glasses to see the scene instead of a clear color will darken; tinted lenses to filter out a large number of Blu-ray, can improve the visual contrast and clarity, Discount Oakley or more severe air pollution in case of wear best effects fog.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by nikeheelsdunk

Mon, 26 Dec 2011 02:37:41 -0600

For every beginning hunter, there are probably a hundred things that are needed when it comes to hunting for the women jordan heels first time. Though it may also include a cell phone or other non-essentials like a mp3 player, it would be good to have a few things needed before going with the hunting group.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Friv

Fri, 16 Dec 2011 20:41:53 -0600

Thanks, very interesting article

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Cheap Bags Sale

Mon, 05 Dec 2011 04:20:36 -0600

Cheap Bags Sale, LV special fabric with imported fabrics.Discount Bags Sale with leather color leather with imports, drip that is changed by the time of oxidation, was unique coral. chanel bag zipper YKK zipper with high quality products, metal does not fade and does not rust, very smooth pull. , This year the new Bags Sale, beauty of the MM Oh, do not miss the opportunity!

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Cheap Oakley Sunglasses Outlet

Mon, 05 Dec 2011 04:09:21 -0600

Oakley Sunglasses Hut has provided the environment for a variety of colors mountain light lens coating, with Iridium? Coated lenses with the use of harsh sunlight and reduce the balance of light transmission, so that the light reaching the eyes of athletes precisely adjusted to produce the best visual . Our G30?Best Oakley Sunglasses Lens color is popular favorite athletes want to enhance the visual contrast of a choice. Oakley VR28?Oakley Lifestyle Sunglasses Has proven to be versatile lens colors, widely used in various light conditions.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Cheap Bags Sale

Mon, 05 Dec 2011 04:09:00 -0600

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Coats Sale

Mon, 05 Dec 2011 04:05:49 -0600

Coats Sale To Whom leisure section of the down jacket and down jacket in general the biggest difference is the surface of the material feels not so cold feeling, more lenient, but the warmth index, which is very high! Long section of the appropriate body fat than the MM, Winter Coats Sale a short slender fit for smaller young MM.The benefits of a long down jacket is warm even to the legs can be! Do not think that fat suit will only make people look fat, it is not true, the big small but can highlight slender legs, buttocks can be greatly Tuicu cover off! Winter Coats Online Down a short casual Comments: short section of the leisure Down for Mini-MM, Winter Coatsthe proportion of elongated legs, looks better than the actual height, the body will not let a little far down deep in all served in! This style of wearing clothes make the MM looks cute and lively.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Sale Ladies Leather Handbags

Mon, 05 Dec 2011 04:05:13 -0600

Allow phonetic typingMost of this season’s no longer the exclusive expedition Sale Ladies Leather Handbags workplace ‘Skeleton’, Black Leather Handbags they seem to be for those who like slow-paced, understand humor, and occasionally a big love like a baby girl tailor-made. . Relax pastoral style Replaced with a small square bag, Previous broad-brush woven bag,Make this a more refined shape,Striking Chromic gentle, sweet,Material is also the finest ostrich and nubuck leather treated,Ladies Leather Handbags From the inside filled with feelings of holiday joy,Gold is still the preferred destination for summer magic light,This year the popular rock but not metal, the metal line of luxury.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by luxe boots outlet

Thu, 01 Dec 2011 02:15:05 -0600

When Chocolate Manitobah Mukluks Winter Boots it comes to motocross boots no one Manitobah Mukluks Classic Snow Boots(Brown) makes them better than AXO. The boots from AXO are designed for men, women and children alike. These combine high quality tensile strength materials along with optimal comfort fitting too. Motocross boots for men The AXO RC6 Tall Vibram Manitobah Mukluks Wrap Mukluk Brown Boots motocross boots remain ever popular amongst all motocross male riders. These come in sizes 7, 8 and 9 and Manitobah Mukluks Short Wrap Boots are available in exciting color combinations of black, silver and white. The prices of each of the motocross boots are extremely reasonable and Australia Luxe Tall Boots when compared to other more expensive brands you can see the value for yourself.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Dr.Dre Casque

Tue, 22 Nov 2011 03:05:52 -0600

Fantastic instrumentals Dr Dre Beatsearphones comprises of a whitebeats by dre Studio New York Yankees , beats by dre Studio Pittsburgh Steelerstangle-free fat-free line type that gets resultsbeats by beats Studio Colorware Chrome: Fantastic has additionally discover eye-catching schokoh?utige earplugs who’ve all the “b” symbol on the fat-free surface court surfacesBeats by Dre Studio Superman para Dwight Howard, Beats By Dr.Dre?Bests By Dre Solo HD Rougencluding a supplies by means of four identifies about replaceable silicone eartipsBests By Dre Solo HD Blanc, along with semi-hard, zippered “b” travel case. At the same time we will not likely keen on bedroom for the cords,Bests By Dre Studio Michael Jackson everyone implement want almost everything better approximately Monster’s suppliesBests By Dre Studio Bleu; it’s a really smaller cutting edgeBeats By Dre Headphones,Beats By Dre Studio Colorful Champagne a small amount of well-known, Beats By Dre Studio Yellowand additionally undeniably eye-catching.Cheap Beats By Dre Fashion-forward creations experience been recently having is much headway on theBeats By Dre Studio White headphone breathing spaceBeats By Dre Solo Purple On-ear. Beats By Dre Studio Dwight HowardThere isn’t an doubting the fact that of the fact that Fantastic Instrumentals just by Dr Dre are often the earphones to try and turn into personallyBeats By Dre Pro In-Ear Golden seen making Beats By Dre Studio Pittsburgh Steelersuse of all of these daysBeats By Dre Studio Red?

"The 4-contact points of software development" by High Performance Alternators

Mon, 21 Nov 2011 20:46:59 -0600

It is essential to have each little piece working. When I’m coding if I cant get one module to work after a while I will go on to a different module, but I’ll keep returning to the buggy module until I get it working :)

Great post!

"The 4-contact points of software development" by Precor Gyms

Thu, 17 Nov 2011 06:24:51 -0600

Awesome stuff. Many thanks for sharing this. This is exactly what I have been looking for.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by nike women heels

Fri, 11 Nov 2011 22:01:32 -0600

Today you wear high heels. As for Women and jordan high heels, this is the inseparable relations, Tom Ford master evidence: “don’t wear the high-heeled shoes woman how talk up sexy?” High heels and sex appeal is relevant? The answer is: “of course!” The temptation of high-heeled shoes Wear women nike heels online in a split second sexy, charm and confident outbreak, twisting the waist is born swaying pose..Worth looking at, perhaps have unexpected harvest.

"The 4-contact points of software development" by mapa

Wed, 09 Nov 2011 06:26:21 -0600

Extra info – thanks, very interesting article

"The 4-contact points of software development" by UGG Kensington

Mon, 31 Oct 2011 22:55:39 -0500

The autumn collection of UGG Kensington are now in stock . The range features Kensington boots.
UGG Kensington Boots catalog has boots, sneakers and slippers are for everyone that wants to keep warn and dry with the ultimate style. UGGs Kensington are the hot boots right now yet there are lots more Ugg cozy feet products to choose from. The winter season selection has an exiting choice in a number of colors.

Kensington UGG Boots Kensington UGGs are fashionable biker type boots that are amazingly comfy. Totally Kensington UGG, 100 % cool. They really are warm too because the insole is authentic sheepskin and so are the lined uppers. The external soles are a particular EVA with synthetic rubber pod inserts, so no chance of slipping and they last forever too.