Object Mentor Blog: The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes

The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes

Dean Wampler — Thu, 04 Sep 2008 21:42:00 -0500

We’ve been having a discussion inside Object Mentor World Design Headquarters about the meaning of the OCP for dynamic languages, like Ruby, with open classes.

For example, in Ruby it’s normal to define a class or module, e.g.,

    
# foo.rb
class Foo
    def method1 *args
        ...
    end
end

and later re-open the class and add (or redefine) methods,

    
# foo2.rb
class Foo
    def method2 *args
        ...
    end
end

Users of Foo see all the methods, as if Foo had one definition.

    
foo = Foo.new
foo.method1 :arg1, :arg2
foo.method2 :arg1, :arg2

Do open classes violate the Open-Closed Principle? Bertrand Meyer articulated OCP. Here is his definition¹.

Software entities (classes, modules, functions, etc.) should be open for extension, but closed for modification.

He elaborated on it here.

... This is the open-closed principle, which in my opinion is one of the central innovations of object technology: the ability to use a software component as it is, while retaining the possibility of adding to it later through inheritance. Unlike the records or structures of other approaches, a class of object technology is both closed and open: closed because we can start using it for other components (its clients); open because we can at any time add new properties without invalidating its existing clients.

Tell Less, Say More: The Power of Implicitness

So, if one client require’s only foo.rb and only uses method1, that client doesn’t care what foo2.rb does. However, if the client also require’s foo2.rb, perhaps indirectly through another require, problems will ensue unless the client is unaffected by what foo2.rb does. This looks a lot like the way “good” inheritance should behave.

So, the answer is no, we aren’t violating OCP, as long as we extend a re-opened class following the same rules we would use when inheriting from it.

If we use inheritance instead:

    
# foo.rb
class Foo
    def method1 *args
        ...
    end
end
...
class DerivedFoo < Foo
    def method2 *args
        ...
    end
end
...
foo = SubFoo.new    # Instantiate different class...
foo.method1 :arg1, :arg2
foo.method2 :arg1, :arg2

One notable difference is that we have to instantiate a different class. This is an important difference. While you can often just use inheritance, and maybe you should prefer it, inheritance only works if you have full control over what types get instantiated and it’s easy to change which types you use. Of course, inheritance is also the best approach when you need all behavioral variants simulateneously, i.e., each variant in one or more objects.

Sometimes you want to affect the behavior of all instances transparently, without changing the types that are instantiated. A slightly better example, logging method calls, illustrates the point. Here we use the “famous” alias_method in Ruby.

    
# foo.rb
class Foo
    def method1 *args
        ...
    end
end
# logging_foo.rb
class Foo
    alias_method :old_method1, :method1
    def method1 *args
        p "Inside method1(#{args.inspect})" 
        old_method1 *args
    end
end
...
foo = Foo.new
foo.method1 :arg1, :arg2

Foo.method1 behaves like a subclass override, with extended behavior that still obeys the Liskov-Substitution Principle (LSP).

So, I think the OCP can be reworded slightly.

Software entities (classes, modules, functions, etc.) should be open for extension, but closed for source modification.

We should not re-open the original source, but adding functionality through a separate source file is okay.

Actually, I prefer a slightly different wording.

Software entities (classes, modules, functions, etc.) should be open for extension, but closed for source and contract modification.

The extra and contract is redundant with LSP. I don’t think this kind of redundancy is necessarily bad. ;) The contract is the set of behavioral expectations between the “entity” and its client(s). Just as it is bad to break the contract with inheritance, it is also bad to break it through open classes.

OCP and LSP together are our most important design principles for effective organization of similar vs. variant behaviors. Inheritance is one way we do this. Open classes provide another way. Aspects provide a third way and are subject to the same design issues.

¹ Meyer, Bertrand (1988). Object-Oriented Software Construction. Prentice Hall. ISBN 0136290493.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by crack

Wed, 08 Feb 2012 10:10:53 -0600

Good artical,I learn something!)) very cool!

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Gerry

Sat, 21 Jan 2012 02:59:25 -0600

Good Information Very nice post

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by backup iphone sms

Wed, 11 Jan 2012 05:23:26 -0600

Take effect to save the file and you can retrieve them when necessary.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by tv guide

Sat, 26 Nov 2011 10:08:05 -0600

thank you once more! great job!

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Richard

Fri, 11 Nov 2011 15:25:27 -0600

Great article, I was just sitting in some outdoor chairs in my university and found this. Thank you! Just what I was looking for.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by canada goose jakke

Sun, 30 Oct 2011 19:55:03 -0500

Om canada goose jakke spørgsmål vedrørende fødevaresikkerhed, canada goose Gruppen af otte forventes canada goose outlet at lancere “Aquila fødevarer belstaff outlet security initiative”, vil være os $ 10-15 milliarderi belstaff støtte begået for landbrugs udvikling i fattigere Canada Goose Ungdom Freestyle lande.Med hensyn til finansforordningen forventes gruppen af otte ledere at være “Lecce rammen” Hot Salg på grundlag af vedtagelsen canada goose jakke af en politikfil, cross-domæne Canada Goose Banff Parka for at styrke tilsynet med banker, institutioner og virksomhedsledelse, og I am legend og har Hot Salg for nylig udgivet selvmord.I dag, efteråret Canada Goose Handsker på ny hylden, ikke kun mode, men vil holde dig tilsluttet på legender af læder.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by christian louboutin

Sun, 30 Oct 2011 05:05:02 -0500

Good artical,I learn something!

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by flac converter

Thu, 27 Oct 2011 02:47:40 -0500

Thank you for sharing, I’ll definitely dig deeper into it.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by ysbearing

Wed, 19 Oct 2011 03:28:49 -0500

Slewing ring is also called slewing bearing, some people called: rotary support, swing support. English Name: slewing bearing or slewing ring bearing or turn table bearing, slewing ring in the real industrial applications is very wide.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Ashley Bowling

Sun, 16 Oct 2011 05:21:08 -0500

When the western sky is especially clear, there is often a red sunset.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Evering2010

Sat, 15 Oct 2011 03:39:11 -0500

Thank you for sharing them with us , I think it’s worth reading

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by best sleep aid

Fri, 30 Sep 2011 12:39:58 -0500

hmm ,i’m not sure if this is what i’m looking for but anyway this is interresting and could be useful some day,thanks for taking time to write such cool stuff

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Uniformes De Fútbol

Fri, 16 Sep 2011 07:21:06 -0500

I really like your article. Please keep on writing excellent posts. To find out more please go to http://baratasfutbolcamiseta.es/ http://baratasfutbolcamiseta.es/category.php?id=9 http://baratasfutbolcamiseta.es/goods.php?id=76 http://www.camisetas-de-futbol.es/ http://www.camisetas-de-futbol.es/category-66-b0-FIFA+del+Copa+del+Mundo.html http://www.camisetas-de-futbol.es/goods-4080-10+11+Holland+Tercel+Blanco+camiseta+del+futbol.html http://www.camisetasfutbolchina.es/ http://www.camisetasfutbolchina.es/category-122-b0-Real+Madrid.html http://www.camisetasfutbolchina.es/goods-4605-11+12+England+Titular+Blando+camiseta+del+futbol.html

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Patio Furniture

Wed, 07 Sep 2011 14:16:21 -0500

Very useful! I was actually looking for something like this. Very efficient! thank you!

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Crystal Jewellery

Thu, 18 Aug 2011 12:38:13 -0500

Great post! Nice and informative, I really enjoyed reading it and will certainly share this post with my friends . Read everything about the different colors of gold

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Android apps developer

Thu, 11 Aug 2011 22:39:14 -0500

This kind of post are always inspiring and i prefer to read this quality content.Its very Interesting open closed object technology… I am surprised to see this information on your blog.. This is amazing blog…thank u…

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Kevin

Sat, 30 Jul 2011 00:31:27 -0500

Good Information Very nice post

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by John

Sat, 30 Jul 2011 00:29:46 -0500

good post, i think so.Thank you!

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by audio converter

Sat, 30 Jul 2011 00:26:00 -0500

you have posted such a effectful article that it will certainly help me.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by casio

Thu, 07 Jul 2011 06:52:10 -0500

thanks its nice great site and i have added in my favorites list

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by commission predators

Fri, 17 Jun 2011 11:30:28 -0500

What a wonderful article! And are doing well on the whole, but their work also has shortcomings.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by virtual spokesperson

Mon, 13 Jun 2011 10:47:44 -0500

where can i read more about Oriented Design inside the dynamic languages world, mainly the Ruby world.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by beats by dr dre headphones

Thu, 09 Jun 2011 03:10:45 -0500

I attempted these beats by dr dre studio out in several genres thinking about which i listen to an eclectic mix Beats By Dr Dre. a washing cloth as well as the manual. Do not purchase any beats by dr dre solo purple products inside the internet unless you’re getting from an Authorized internet DealerBeats By Dre Just Solo. We are reliable provide good beats by dr dre pro black by reduced price.

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by Jewellery

Sat, 04 Jun 2011 06:03:16 -0500

Online UK costume and fashion jewellery shop with, Online UK costume and fashion jewellery shop with, Online UK costume and fashion jewellery shop with, Online UK costume and fashion jewellery shop with,

"The Open-Closed Principle for Languages with Open Classes" by f350 leveling kit

Fri, 13 May 2011 01:54:42 -0500

I love reading your article and I hope I can read more. Thanks :-)