What's all this nonsense about Katas? 237
There has been an increase in interest in Software Katas of late. What is all this buzz about, and why might it be important?
Several years ago (Pragmatic) Dave Thomas started a special blog about coding katas. The idea was simple: Professionals practice.
This thought might not have occurred to you before; but it’s self-evidently true. Professional musicians practice. Professional dancers practice. Doctors practice. Soldiers practice. Indeed, any kind of professional craftsman or artisan must practice their adopted trade in order to execute it well when it counts.
Dave’s point was that professional programmers need to practice like any other professional. He set forth a number of simple exercises and problems that programmers could solve during their practice time. He also suggested that practice time needs to be scheduled and protected as part of the normal routine of a software developer.
At XP2005 in Shefield, UK, I attended Laurent Bossavit’s and Emmanuel Gaillot’s Coding Dojo session. I blogged about it at the time. I left that session with a different view of what a Kata might be. In Dave Thomas’ view a kata is an exercise to solve. Each time you solve it you try a different approach. Dave’s notion is that a kata is a way to explore the solution space of a problem. But in Martial arts a kata is something different; it is a set of motions that one memorizes in minute detail. A martial arts kata is a precisely executed dance. I left Sheffield with the idea that a coding kata could be more like a martial arts kata.
About a year ago, Corey Haines (our wandering minstrel of code) stopped by and told me about some mini-conferences that had adopted the notion of coding kata. What he described sounded more like a group dance than a bunch of people independently solving a given problem. This got me thinking. So at the next Software Craftsmanship meeting at 8th Light (Which, not coincidentally, takes it’s name from a martial arts philosophy) I conducted a simple kata session in dojo style.
I, acting as the Sen Sei, had everyone file in to the room as they would to a dojo. I had them put their green bands on their wrists (mine was black!). I bade them to sit, and then gestured for silence. For the next 15 minutes I led them through the Prime Factors Kata in Java without uttering a word (well, almost). I would write a simple test case, then gesture for them to do the same. Then I would make the test pass, and again gesture for them to repeat my moves.
Then, this Fall, I attended Programming with the Stars at Agile 2009. As I watched the contestants perform their programming sessions, I realized that they were not simply demonstrating programming prowess; indeed they were competing in how well they performed their session. That’s when it struck me. This was a performance art!
It seems absurd to think of programming as a performance art. And yet watching those people up on stage working through routines that they had clearly practiced over and over again, was delightfully entertaining to me, and to the crowd. There were cheers and applause when a performing pair did something especially well. There was laughter when a pair executed a clever joke in code, or in behavior. For programmers, watching other programmers perform well practiced routines was fun!
Now I had seen martial arts katas executed as performance art during competitions. Indeed, it is a beautiful thing to watch a skilled and well practiced martial artist peform a kata. And that started me thinking. Why would a martial artist practice these forms so intensely that they could be performed as an art?
The goal of martial arts is not to perform on stage. The goal of martial arts is self defense! And yet, when a martial artist is at the peak of his skill, his practice takes on the quality of a performance art. When you watch a skilled martial artist perform, you know you don’t want to fight him. The performance is a demonstration, and a realization, of mastery.
And yet the performance is not the goal. No martial artist practices his art so that they can perform on stage. A martial artist practices to achieve personal perfection in the art of self defense. The fact that the practice can be performed is a (pleasant) side effect.
Could it be that these coding kata that we’ve been dabbling with for the last few years could be performed? Is there a benefit to practicing them so much that performance is an option? Is there really any reason for a programmer to create and then memorize a routine down to the level of individual keystrokes? Is there profit to be gained from practicing that routine so thoroughly that you can do it at high speed with virtually no errors? This August I decided to find out.
I started with the Prime Factors Kata in Java, and set it to music inspired by this video of dancing kites. The piece is about 4 minutes long, and I figured I’d need about twice that, so I found two different version of the music and played them back to back. But working in Java is ponderous, and I could not complete the kata before the two pieces had finished. So I switched to Ruby. Using Ruby and Rspec I was able to finish the Kata with plenty of time to spare.
Thereupon began an evolution. Since I had time, I added more features to the kata. As I improved in my practice I found I had even more time, so I added even more features. I refined and polished. I refactored my refactorings. I trimmed keystrokes, and learned many new keyboard shortcuts in the process. I completely abandoned the mouse; and then later reacquired it for flourishes and highlights (but never for actual coding).
Week after week, I set aside 30 minutes or so every day to practice, and practice, and practice—just the way I used to practice my Jiu Jitsu Katas. I would practice on airplanes while flying to clients. I would practice in bed with my laptop in my lap. I would practice late at night in hotel rooms after a long day consulting for clients. I would practice early in the morning before shower and breakfast. And the practice started to pay off.
Ten weeks later I finally decided I was ready to create a screencast. I reduced my screen resolution to 1024X768. I configured SnapZ ProX to record the whole screen at 80% size. And I began to record.
Performing a coding kata in time to music is a very difficult thing to do. Maintaining the timeline is critical. There are very few errors that you can effectively recover from. If you miss a stroke, the whole sequence melts down. And melt down it did. Over and over and over again. I spent weeks trying to record a reasonably good session. I must have done hundreds of takes. It was very frustrating.
But day by day I got better and better at it. Finally, after weeks of trying, I got what I consider to be a recording that, though not perfect, is good enough to present. You can watch that recording here.
Has this paid off in the regular programming I do? I think it has. My mouse usage is much less than it used to be. I know a much larger number of keyboard shortcuts than I used to, and I can use them almost instinctively. My typing and accuracy have improved quite a bit, and I now type more punctuation and number keys without looking. So, yes, I think the effort has paid off; though I’m not at all sure the payoff compensates for the effort.
But something else compensates for the effort. Making this recording was fun—it was a lot of fun. And that’s probably the real answer to the question posed in the title of this blog.
Interesting video. I’d have never thought to be in a situation where critiquing a programming piece based on it’s use of musical phrasing is a possibility. If nothing else I think it lends credence to calling coding a craft not a science.
While i was reading some of the text on katacasts I had an odd thought (may have been echoed by others so no claim to being the first to think this). One thing a friend mentioned about some of the katas he did (i think in kung fu but quite possibly wrong) was that he was paired with another student who was doing the “opposing kata”. That is to say when one was doing a strike, the pair was doing the appropriate block.
It might be an interesting experiment to attempt a dojo style kata with pair programming built in. The hard part would be making it useful without being hokey.
Kind of off topic, at around 6:56 you move the initialisers for factors and divisor onto the same line. I would have thought that having them on separate lines was cleaner. Is preferring them on a single line a rubyism, or are my old c defenses getting in the way?
Jon, I thought craft and science are not mutually exclusive. Historically, I’d say craft usually comes before Science.
Watching the kata was a great way to start the day (I caught your tweet before I got up, in UTC+1). I think it’s interesting that programming katas are returning to the roots, so to speak, and I think it is time that we had different words for when we try to solve a known problem in our own way and when we try to repeat the ways of a master. Both are useful ways to practice programming and deserve their own fora.
Since this is a kata of the copy-the-sensei kind, it would be really useful to know what keystrokes you were using. E.g., I believe that Corey Haines uses KeyCastr in his LCD Numbers Kata.
BTW, the link to Textile syntax above the comment box is broken since the sad disappearance of Why the lucky stiff.
Jon, I’ve performed a longer kata with a partner. Both we and the audience seemed to like it.
An interesting point was that with this hour long kata, the shortest it’s taken us while pairing has been 20% less than the shortest it’s taken solo. I was surprised to see a time benefit from pairing after having practiced a lot solo.
Bob, enjoyed your video. Thanks for showing us.
En lieu of holding up a lighter to get an encore, kudos :-)
Perhaps solving the Navier-Stokes existence problem next?
(Now to go out and find a fixed-price project that needs a Prime Number component in ruby!)
I just watched your video. Nice :-).
I am no Ruby coder so I can not really judge if it is good Ruby style to do more than one thing per line. (Given that Ruby has some roots common with Perl that might be the case…)
Regarding your Rspec: You are treating the whole functionality as a black box and are only asserting if several results are correct. But that way IMHO you are not really making any requirements explicit. To me the biggest benefit of a BDD style is that in the end you end up with executable requirements/specs and not just examples that seem to work. So I would suggest having something like the following as a spec: 1. primeFactors(n<1) => undefined 2. primeFactors(n=1) => [] 3. all elements of primeFactors(n>1) multiplied == n 4. every element in primeFactors(n>1) is a prime number
I find useful the training with Kata to myself to improve how I work with limited time (setting priorities) and how I recover from errors (dealing with unexpected events). Since I’m primary a .NET/VS guy I can also simulate uncertainty working with Java/Eclipse For this scope I find interesting to try always different katas.
Maybe now it is time to give a try also with the training you suggested.
Bravo for the performance!
awesome,
that must have been murder to get right…
I find useful the training with Kata to myself
two words: amazing performance!
Thank you! You Prime Factors kata video inspired me.
One word: Thanks!
Been a programmer (in one form or another) since days with TI/40A and Apple IIe. But the Prag folks and, now, your blog is helping to revive the joy in this craft. Thanks!
software development is a bit more than typing exercise.
I worked on your prime number kata a few weeks ago but couldn’t figure out any way to leave comments on that page, so it seems like an opportune time here.
I coded it up myself before looking at your solution. Mine was a dozen or two lines of Python, so I was looking forward to seeing some elegant 2- or 3- lines solution in Java. But when I looked at it, I didn’t even think it worked.
At first I thought it would report 4 and 6 and other numbers as possible factors, since it was testing those values. I looked at the tests, figuring the tests would show me that it did indeed skip those values, only to realize none of the numbers tested had a factor greater than 3. I really would have preferred some tests which contained, say, 5 or better 19 as factors.
That’s not saying your solution is wrong, only that the tests aren’t telling me enough to make me happy that the code is right, without actually looking at the code.
Once I figured out why the code worked and wouldn’t report ‘4’ and other non-primes as factors, my next thought was on how slow the algorithm was. It really is testing every single possible number less than the current candidate, including composites which by construction cannot be factors.
That’s pointed out a difference in how we understood the problem. When I’ve had to deal with primes it’s been for number in the range up to 2 * * 32. I coded my solution for that expectation, and with the ability to scale up a bit higher. I used the Sieve of Eratosthenes to generate the prime factors I used as tests.
Your code doesn’t even take into consideration the observation that you only need to test up to sqrt(candidate) so your performance is O(n) in the worst case, when it should be O(sqrt(n)). By comparison, if you only test prime factors then worst case is O(?(sqrt(n)) or about O(sqrt(n)/ln(n)).
For a test case, try 2 * * 31-1 which is max 32-bit signed int and a Mersenne prime. It will take your code a very long time to solve, while my Python code takes 4.5 seconds, most of which is spent in generating the 6543 primes from 2 to 2 * * 16.
Thinking about your kata, the problem is that it doesn’t provide any sort of idea about domain applicability. If the factors really are only going to be 2 and 3 then it’s easy enough to just use those as the only test factors. In fact, you should be able to pass your tests with “while(;n%2==0;n/=2){primes.add(2);}” “while(;n%3==0;n/=3){primes.add(3);}”.
If it’s a small range, then pre-coded primes would also be a better solution than what you did. There are only 6543 primes to handle all numbers up to 2 * * 31.
I feel like you haven’t developed enough tests to show that your code really works. You need to test numbers which don’t have 2 and 3 as factors. 49(=7 * 7) and 91(=7 * 13) would be good ones.
You also have to have something which tests the range of applicability, like 2 * * 31-1 if you expect numbers that large.
I ended up being disappointed with this kata because it makes no mention of these problems, and uses a solution worse than one understood by the ancient Greeks, as well as many modern high school students. There was no real world use case driving the problem domain and so what is really a toy solution does work, but as it’s a toy solution and underspecified problem, I don’t think it’s one which should be promoted as a good example of a kata.
Even if you leave it as a beginning practice piece, you need to have some commentary to point out the limitations.
Just went through your video at http://www.vimeo.com/2499161 . You brought up the Sieve of Eratosthenes approach but called this “much more elegant”. The only reason it’s elegant is the driving problem is answers for your son’s homework problem. In that case, no prime divisor is going to be larger than perhaps 19 so you can hard-code the first few primes and use those as candidates. The result will be faster than your algorithm because yours makes tests which are known to be unneeded.
If you have values larger than this then your assumptions (“the density of primes is high”) will no longer be valid and you would have to go to some other solution. Again, that list is only about 6,543 values to cover everything up to 2**32, and it will be quite fast.
I like the kata idea. One thing that occurs to me, however, is that typically these are associated with critique and instruction. One doesn’t simply practice karate in isolation.
Where would a software craftsperson get feedback on his/her technique?
One thing that occurs to me, however, is that typically these are associated with critique and instruction. One doesn’t simply practice karate in isolation.
Thank you! You Prime Factors kata video inspired me.
thank you for sharing.
I see a lot of new video with Kata performance.
I provide some interesting background about live coding here:
- Hacking Perl in Nightclubs http://www.perl.com/pub/a/2004/08/31/livecode.html
- THE LIVE CODING OF SLUB http://www.litsciarts.org/slsa07/slsa07-229.pdf
- LIVE CODING: AN OVERVIEW http://iem.at/projekte/publications/paper/live/live.pdf
Thank you very much, I find useful the training with Kata
Thank you for sharing the training with Kata
welcome to http://www.uggboots4buy.com/ l,will have a unexpection.
Living without an aim is like sailing without a compass. with a new http://www.handbags4buy.com/ idea is a crank until the idea succeeds.
all products are high quality but low price,welcome to http://www.uggjordanghd.com/.
>Very quietly I take my leave.To seek a dream in http://www.edhardy-buy.com/ starlight.
nfl jerseys nhl jerseys nba jerseys mlb jerseys soccer jerseys
that real significant changes are often the ones that go unnoticed, because they Make Things Work As They Are Supposed To.
It’s realy a funny cartoon, but I don’t found a sad story.. Sorry
most of people want to buy a pair of comfortable shoes but don`t know where to buy the comfortable and how to choice the shoes she like here is a website if you have frre time you come come here http://www.buy2shoes.com
I coded it up myself before looking at your solution
That’s pointed out a difference in how we understood the problem.
Thinking about your kata, the problem is that it doesn’t provide any sort of idea about domain applicability.
come here and share with us the nice shoes http://www.buy2shoes.com
most of nice shoes in here, hit our website http://www.buy2shoes.com
It’s realy a funny cartoon, but I don’t found a sad story.. Sorry
Bull-puncher knickers is always at leisure wear the limelight, cowboy comfortable and cool and refreshing knickers shading effect, it is become big period of change garments according to the spring love and melody. Loose t-shirts , vests even swimsuit can matching, become do not fall convention of change garments according to the collocation of the election.
Stripe unlined upper garment is joker sheet is tasted, pants matchs skirt is harmonious. Tie-in pants, leisure, a handsome capable of taste, tie-in skirt, appear very college diversified, melting and lovely breath, have reduced the magical age. Stripe unlined upper garment skirt collocation of whole summer, let you are young.
MBT stands for “Masai Barefoot Technology,” and the shoes are designed to simulate walking in sand. http://www.buy2shoes.com
http://www.buy2shoes.com I want to share with you the nice shoes
Thank you very much for sharing all those set of lovely and top I am newly learning the use of in and this I think would really help me in my assignments.
This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work.You put really very helpful information. Keep it up. Keep blogging. Looking to reading your next post.
yes thanks very much for the indepth video and following feedback
It’s realy a funny cartoon, but I don’t found a sad story.. Sorry
Thank you very much for this blog.I like its.As to me it’s good job.I come to this site then read this article and i will read your next articles.
You’ve pretty much answered all my doubts with this and have done a great job with the article.
cheap VPS
http://www.bowljersey.com/products/MLB-Jerseys-c5_p1.html" target="_blank">MLB Jerseys
best deals on original chea chi flat irons with some new arrived.
Interesting post. I have been wondering about this issue,so thanks for posting.
buy cd’s
Hermes belt, Hermes belts, Hermes Mens belts, Hermes belts for men.
Fashion, a general term for the style and custom prevalent at a given time, in its most common usage refers to costume or clothing style. The more technical term, costume, has become so linked in the public eye with the term “fashion” that the more general term “costume” has in popular use mostly been relegated to special senses like fancy dress or masquerade wear, while the term “fashion” means clothing generally, and the study of it.
so much nonsense here about these katas
dancers practice. Doctors practice. Soldiers practice. Indeed, any kind of professi
I agree with your 1st statement…
i like your blog .i hope you are happy
there are too many good read here, can’t stop
Thanks great. It is very informative. We have learned much from it.
Excel en PDF Convertisseur s’installe dans votre ordinateur comme un imprimante virtuelle, il supporte convertir tous les formats imprimable en document PDF, tels que Excel(xls, xlsx), TXT, les images (JPEG, GIF, PNG, BMP, EMF, EWF, TIFF), etc, compatible avec Microsoft Office 2003/2007/2010. Huit formats de sortie : PS, EPS, PDF, PNG, JPEG, BMP, PCX, et TIFF, compatible avec Adobe Acrobat 9.0.Télécharger gratuitement Excel en PDF Convertisseur et expérimenter ce logiciel.
Here is very different. Thank you
In fact, you know. the contacts and SMS have more values than an iphone’s own value. You can spend money to buy a new iPhone, However, if you get your SMS and contacts lost, it is hard to retrieve them. So, you need backup them.
Developers often talk about Technical Debt saying its slowing.So a small mess grows into a bigger mess every time someone touches it
I am happy to find so many useful information here in the post, thanks for sharing it here. I hope you will be adding more.
To work like any other professional for professional programmers, David set a forth number of simple exercises and problems that programmers could solve during their practice time ..
To be a good programmer is difficult and noble. The hardest part of making real a collective vision of a software project is dealing with one’s coworkers and customers. Writing computer programs is important and takes great intelligence and skill. But it is really child’s play compared to everything else that a good programmer must do to make a software system that succeeds for both the customer and myriad colleagues for whom she is partially responsible. In this essay I attempt to summarize as concisely as possible those things that I wish someone had explained to me when I was twenty-one.
I have a mummified squirrel that fell on my boyfriend’s head when he was tearing out a ceiling. lol It needs a new home!
These databases are typically managed with functional techniques, like map-reduce.
Great set of resources – I think this is the biggest oversight people make. Iran
Your post will be rather good, and I’m sure some will find it interesting because it’s about a topic that’s as widely discussed as others. Some may even find it useful. I have learned a significant amount of useful information from your post. Thanks so much for your post. Keep sharing. College Address
Im glad I came across to this article. Thanks for the tips and links to sites. I will be sure to take advantage of it.Teaching Certificate
The post is written in very a good manner and it entails many useful information for me. I am happy to find your distinguished way of writing the postUniversity Addresses
Thanks for giving us objective information, much appreciate this!
I’m not sure if the Katas are actually happenning but it sounds like a great idea. Programming Katas – I can dig it. We should have Katas for about 10 other things I can think of.
If you mean to find great shoes for your children puma speed trainers also provides a mixture of finicky and affordable shoes for them. There are a lot of choices, it is up ring call,Ugg Boots, after by people that indigence an incredible quantity of column. This will make the customers happier. If you are often tangled in Singapore womens puma future cat shoes sale at Sainte Marie that could enhance operational efficiency, range visibility and turnaround time,” said Desmond Chan, managing boss, South Asia, Menlo Worldwide Logistics. “Our multi-client facility in Boon Lay Way provides puma trainers with different flag. puma uk’s youngest targets are toddlers. The puma for sale shoes are incredibly affordable, yet they still hold the grace. Wearing comfortable shoes will help children exploit better.
Merry Christmas! What’s your most desire present you want to get? Hmm maybe you and me have one thing in commend, the white iphone 4.
feel the real beauty inside u…see completemakeup process , from applying foundation to smokey eyes u can find here every thing! beauty
feel the real beauty inside u…see completemakeup process , from applying foundation to smokey eyes u can find here every thing! beauty
Good thing you made this blog, Provillus It might be an interesting experiment to attempt a dojo style kata with pair programming built in.
I am really enjoying the theme/design of your website. Do you ever run into any internet browser compatibility problems? A small number of my blog readers have complained about my website not operating correctly in Explorer but looks great in Safari. Do you have any suggestions to help fix this issue?
if you want something to beauty you life,i would introduce you to the women’s handbags store.
PS:TKS for all you job of share.
I have nothing to say but thanks to this awesome article.
Thanks for giving us a great information. I really appreciate this!
hockey jerseys discount custom football jerseys buy cheap jerseys href=”http://www.cheapjerseys20.com”>sale youth sports jerseys soccer sports jerseys buy nfl team apparel,soccer jerseys buy shop nfl youth jerseys,nba hat sports apparel shop nfl jerseys wholesale, wholesale nfl football jerseys,nfl hats, oakley sunglasses discount, Dallas Cowboys jerseys,football jerseys, wholesale 2010 Pro Bowl jerseys, oakley radar sunglasses, Best youth football jerseys softball jerseys wholesaler custom football jerseys buy player jerseys, custom basketball jerseys nba jerseys,customized nfl jerseys, wholesale,nfl team jerseys,football jerseys, wholesale sports jerseys,soccer jerseys, wholesale baseball jerseys mlb, nfl jerseys discount,cheap nfl gear, nfl jerseys sale,notre dame sports,
Nice post. Its really worth to share and spread.
Incontinence products
All I can say for this post is , “GREAT”.
Thanks for share! I agree with you. The artical improve me so much! I will come here frequently. iPhone Contacts Backup For Mac can help you backup iphone contact to mac.
I really like this essay. Thank you for writing it so seriously. I want to recommend it for my friends strongly. iPad to Mac Transfer can help you transfer music, movie, photo, ePub, PDF, Audiobook, Podcast and TV Show from ipad to mac freely.
I think it is time that we had different words for when we try to solve a known problem in tenant Screening our own way and when we try to repeat the ways of a master
a href=”http://www.cheapjerseys20.com”>soccer sports jerseys buy nhl hockey uniforms shup, Dallas Cowboys jerseys sale, replica jerseys, buy nfl jerseys,NCAA jerseys, cheap nfl youth jerseys,
great work
Visit
vendita computer
lago di caldonazzo
I think it is time that we had different words for when we try to solve a known problem in our own way and tenant Screening when we try to repeat the ways of a master. Both are useful ways to practice programming and deserve their own fora.
Thinking about your kata, the problem is tenant Screening that it doesn’t provide any sort of idea about domain applicability.
It seems absurd to think of programming as a performance art. And yet watching those people up on stage working through routines that they had clearly practiced over and over again, was delightfully entertaining to me, and to the crowd.
Gucci clutches http://www.max-luxury.com/gucci-handbags-gucci-clutches-c-72_78.html Gucci clutches
Cool, I figured out why the code worked and wouldn’t report ‘4’ and other non-primes as factors, my next thought was on how slow the algorithm was.
Cool, I figured out why the code worked and wouldn’t report ‘4’ and other non-primes as factors, my next thought was on how slow the algorithm was. Proactol
Ct Credit Bureau is a nationwide, full service and accurate information for tenant screening, employment screening and mortgage credit reporting company.
I would have never even thought of that! I swear i Am learning so much just from reading these forumn! Thank you sweet Diva!
I am trying to get a visual! You mean through the TOP of the weft or the BACK??? I’ve seen hair through the top from time to time with hand tied wefts. Sometime
Fabians if it wasn’t worth my time to try and get you fired I would try and do so you are an idiot who writes articles
Also, Bill is a genius at stopping an offenses number 1 option at RB and WR.
There was no real world use case driving the problem domain and so what is really a toy solution does work, but as it’s a toy solution and underspecified problem, I don’t think it’s one which should be promoted as a good example of a kata.
Very useful stuff in here!
Also, Bill is a genius at stopping an offenses number 1 option at RB and WR.Very useful stuff in here!
Very useful stuff in here!
Buy $10 Replica Designer Sunglasses with 3-day FREE SHIPPING
Very useful information indeed!! Thank you for taking time to share it with the readers, I am more than happy to have come across it. Keep up the good work.
who is looking at learning the piano there are many websites all over the internet that offer classical piano music lessons and a lot of them are for free. For the player who already knows the piano but is looking. cheap mary poppins tickets
Dave’s point was that professional programmers need to practice like any other professional. He set forth a number of simple exercises and problems that programmers could solve during their practice time. He also suggested that practice time needs to be scheduled and protected as part of the normal routine of a software developer.
The summer is coming,there are so many all kinds of sunglasses.
There are various kinds of Hermes belts available to match your needs.
There are various kinds of Hermes belts available to match your needs.
Useful information will I follow your posts. Social Network
Almost any situation--good or bad --is affected by the attitude we bring to. Adversity reveals genius; fortune conceals it. As fruit needs not only sunshine but cold nights and chilling showers to ripen it, so character needs not only joy but trial and difficulty to mellow it. Although the world is full of suffering, it is full also of the overcoming of it. tiffany and co outlet
five finger kso
five finger kso
Do you want to learn something about handbags?Then you can come to http://www.gucci-sito-ufficiale.com/ .You can find gucci sito ufficiale and get a nice gucci borsa.
It is a nice thing to browse the http://www.polooutlet-store.net/ and find a beautiful ralph lauren shirt there.
Very useful stuff in here!
Our products is good,all kinds of shoes and clothes, NFL Custom Jerseys 2010
World cup jerseys 2010
World cup jerseys
welcome to our website
http://www.nfl-jerseys-sale.org/
http://www.nfl-jerseys-sale.net/
http://www.custom-nfl-jerseys.org/
Strongly recommended for shopping at Hermes belt store.
that is so good!thanks
Yes i agree with it.
internette görüntülü olarak okey oyunu oyna, gerçek kisilerle tanis, turnuva heyecanini yasa.
It is great post .I like it
I thought katas meant a type of Japanese sword. Glad it was fun for you.
I preferred the cloud as it more underline a potentially complex dependency good system
They are able to share and express their best features as rural community. They understand that maximizing their good potential together will give them better future for their next generation.
This could be the great bag for carrying numerous of your belongings.
This is such a great resource that you are providing and it’s really easy for me to SEE what you were talking about.
Perfect Human Hair Wigs for you! There are more than 4000 pieces different kinds of full lace wigs in stock now. Our lace wigs are made of 100% Indian Remy or Virgin human hair to make it look like the real one. Human hair wigs have become extremely popular today. You would be surprised if you know how many people were wearing human hair wigs around you! Human hair lace wigs are made so well today that it is easy to use to have a completely new look or enhance your natural beauty.
Now a days the increment in interest in Software Katas of late are being noticed. That’s really boring….
Very good I will recommended to more friends.Good luck! http://www.gzqiyue88.com/">HeidelBerg Parts http://www.gzqiyue88.com/">Printing Spare Parts
Online UK costume and fashion jewellery shop with, Online UK costume and fashion jewellery shop with,
Your five steps to a successful start to work with Wordpress helped me a lot, you would know how many hours I spent setting it up and trying to understand how everything works, but now armed with the knowledge of your data, I can easily cope with this problem!)))))
I was also thinking about katas last night, but It seems thath they are very well aware of that !! huhh..
nonsense about Katas? now no comments!! :)
very cool blog ! i like the layout too ! keep up the good work !
Thanks for useful information. It would be useful to know about Sigma Ukraine
you give the best high power leds
The food here is so authentic which makes it so good. I definitely recommend going here in the future.
Be sure that you have never had any yves saint laurent shoes regrets in your yves saint laurent booties life which only lasts for a few decades. Laugh or cry as you like discount yves saint laurent shoes , and it is meaningless to oppress yves saint laurent boots yourself. Among thousands of people, you meet those you have
Coding Katas in time to music is impossible! At least extremely difficult. bed bug spray diatomaceous earth food grade
nice read…
Among thousands of people,
I really like your site. Great info here about the style of blouses. Thank you so much for these info.
power tools
Great post! Nice and informative, I really enjoyed reading it and will certainly share this post with my friends . Read everything you ever wanted to know about gemstones
Good article more useful to me, I will continue to pay attention, and I love discount evening wedding dress,I hope you lot just my site! discount aline wedding dresses http://www.tofuchina.com
Belstaff Leather Jackets are currently become more and more fashionable,specially in recent years,lots of women has changed their cumbersome marten coats to stylish Womens Belstaff Leather Jackets in winter. Belstaff Motorcycle Jackets not simply will retain warm but also extremely eye-catching.They can express your frame of Mens Belstaff Leather Jackets mind and character. At this time we can discover women wearing unique variations of from blazers, reversible jackets, outdoor jackets, coats to suede jackets. They are various kinds of Belstaff Clothing in the market now and you certainly can discover one that your mind wishes.Among all the jacket brand,Belstaff one of the most popular. Belstaff Bags have dedicated to jacket research and manufacturing for longer than 80 years,80 years’ reserch and study make Belstaff grow to be one of the top brand in clothing market,especially the Mens Belstaff Blouson UK has earned huge popularity.The latest fashion statements in the Belstaff jacket designs for women are the class ladies motorcycle jackets. Womens Belstaff motorcycle jacket will not be only for wearing when you are riding a motorcycle. Belstaff Travel Bags for women come in almost any style you can imagine. For more information about Belstaff Mens Boots.
I am a regular visitor of this website and always found new post or blog, I hope you better your website quality! web info
I wanted to thank you for this excellent read!! I definitely loved every little bit of it.Cheers for the info!!!! & This is the perfect blog for anyone who wants to know about this topic. You know so much its almost hard to argue with you .
You are very cool! I dont suppose I have read something similar to this before. So nice to search out somebody with authentic applying for grants this subject. I really appreciate starting this up. Your website is one area that is needed on the net. Totally a helpful project for bringing new things for the web! Be grateful you for spending time to speak about this, I think strongly about that and delight in reading read more about this topic. Whenever possible, just like you become expertise, do you mind updating your web site with a lot more details? It can be highly great for me. Two thumb up in this article! I haven’t checked in here for some time because I thought it was getting boring, but the last few posts are really good quality so I guess I’ll add you back to my daily bloglist. You deserve it my friend. insurance guides
The Dark Knight Rises
download hollywood movies free
Salespeople role-play, a lot of musicians only practice in their head: After a certain degree of ability that’s more than enough to build up muscle memory for performance, it’s similar in the inner martial arts. C programmers constantly write the same for-loop patterns, over and over again.
Canada Goose Outlet is Marmot 8000M Parka. The Marmot 8000M Parka is really a waterproof, breathable jacket with 800 fill canada goose jacket feathers. It truly is design and light colored shell is produced for trendy, but uncomplicated, protection from cold temperatures. Reinforced shoulders, elbows and adjustable waist and hem make the Marmot a perfect alternate for skiing and other outdoor sports that want fairly a bit of arm motion. The 8000M Parka weighs three lbs., comes in bonfire and black colours and might be stuffed and stored like a sleeping bag to your convenience.This is one of well-know and prime down jacket brands.Hope our friends like its!Like canada goose womens and Canada Goose Expedition Parka.There are wholesale canada goose.
Disciple to ask teacher: “could you tell mebelstaff jakets something about the human odd?” Answer: “they rush to grow up, and then bemoaned the lost childhood; they to health, and soon forbelstaff boots money in exchange for money to restore health. For their future, the but again ignored at the anxiety ofbelstaff bags happiness. So now, they don’t live in the present, also do not live in the future. They live as if will never die, before he died, and as though they had never lived.
Disciple to ask teacher: “could you tell mebelstaff jakets something about the human odd?” Answer: “they rush to grow up, and then bemoaned the lost childhood; they to health, and soon forbelstaff boots money in exchange for money to restore health. For their future, the but again ignored at the anxiety ofbelstaff bags happiness. So now, they don’t live in the present, also do not live in the future. They live as if will never die, before he died, and as though they had never lived.
The stuff here is pretty cool and awesome. I got the meaning clearly and need no longer time to understand it. It’s really interesting.
I like the supra shoes very much.The Supra Thunder Hightop have some different colores and stlyes that match the fashion clothes.
I respect your work , thanks for all the informative articles.
Thank you very much for posting and sharing this great article. It is so interesting. I want to know some other information about this site. So pleasewholesale computer memory
It is really a Great post. Nice to see fine things in Vancouver, a city I love and where I have spent a fair amount of time over the years. I like nice photos and designs also.
This post gives truly quality information. I’m definitely going to look into it. Really very useful tips are provided here. Thank you so much. Keep up the good works.
Several years ago (Pragmatic) Dave Thomas started a special blog about coding katas. The idea was simple: Professionals practice
http://www.capshoponline.com/
_ great writer’s effort. Thanks for the info about katas.
nice here, thank you for sharing China granite China Stone China Marble Chinese Granite Chinese Marble Imported Granite Imported Marble Artificial Stone Dyed Granite Granite Marble Slab Natural Stone wholesale Granite wholesale Stone wholesale Marble wholesale Granite slab wholesale Marble slab granite tile marble tile Granite countertop Marble countertop Granite stone countertop Marble stone countertop Artificial stone countertop countertop Granite kitchen countertop Marble Kitchen countertop Slate Quartzite Slate stone Slate cultural stone . welcome to us .
nice here. thank you . we sell China granite China Stone China Marble Chinese Granite Chinese Marble Imported Granite Imported Marble Artificial Stone Dyed Granite Granite Marble Slab Natural Stone wholesale Granite wholesale Stone wholesale Marble wholesale Granite slab wholesale Marble slab granite tile marble tile Granite countertop Marble countertop Granite stone countertop Marble stone countertop Artificial stone countertop countertop Granite kitchen countertop Marble Kitchen countertop Slate Quartzite Slate stone Slate cultural stone . welcome to us .
asd asd+0fas8d0+dd
asdfs df+gsd22211
asa sd+0f9as+96sss
http://www.capshoponline.com/
All things come to those who wait All things must pass All work and no play makes Jack a dull boy
we can supply all kinds of stone productd,like China granite and China Stone and China Marble and Chinese Granite and Chinese Marble and Imported Granite and Imported Marble and Artificial Stone and Dyed Granite and Granite Marble Slab and Natural Stone and wholesale Graniteand wholesale Stone wholesale Marble and wholesale Granite slab wholesale Marble slab and granite tile and marble tile Granite countertop and Marble countertop Granite stone countertop and Marble stone countertop Artificial stone countertop and countertop and Granite kitchen countertop and Marble Kitchen countertop and Slate Quartzite and Slate stone and Slate cultural stone
Slewing ring is also called slewing bearing, some people called: rotary support, swing support. English Name: slewing bearing or slewing ring bearing or turn table bearing, slewing ring in the real industrial applications is very wide. http://www.1stbearing.com
Belstaff Belstaff Jacken Belstaff Outlet Belstaff Damen Belstaff Herren Belstaff Taschen canada goose outlet belstaff Founded in 1924 by Eli Belovitch and his son in law Harry Grosberg in Staffordshire, Belstaff produced all-weather jackets for motorcyclists, and was the first company to ever use waxed cotton. The company later created weather-protective jackets for other uses, goggles (primarily for the growing aviation market), gloves and several other garments intended to keep the wearer warm, dry and safe.Belstaff became a subsidiary of James Halstead in 1948–a company also famous in later years for the success of the Australian brand Driza-Bone.
??? ????1856??????????? ????????1835??????????? 1924??” ??? ????”??????????????????????????? ??????????? ??? ? ( Burberry) ??? ??????1856????????? ??? ???????????? ??? ??????????????????? ???????????? ? ??????????? ??? ???.
?? ?? ??????????????? ?? ?????????? ?? ?1968??????? ?? ???????????? ????????? ?? ???????? ?? ??????? ?? ??????? ?? ???????? ?????? ?????5 ?????????TOMS ??????????? ????????????????????????? ????????????Supra ????????? ?????????????? ??????
very post
I just wanted to comment & say keep up the quality work. I’ve bookmarked your blog just now and I’ll be back to read more in the future my friend! Also well-chosen colors on the theme it goes well with the blog in my modest opinion yhm20110408
mbt shoes that calls for its inspiration from unstable surfaces is bound to provide some extremely basic benefits. yhm20110408
Christian+Loubontin+Boots.html”>Disount Christian Louboutin I just wanted to comment & say keep up the quality work. I’ve bookmarked your blog just now and I’ll be back to read more in the future my friend! Also well-chosen colors on the theme it goes well with the blog in my modest opinion yhm20110408
mbt shoes that calls for its inspiration from unstable surfaces is bound to provide some extremely basic benefits. yhm20110408
Christian+Loubontin+Boots.html”>Disount Christian Louboutin
Louis Vuitton Outlet Store in contrast to if buying throughout local shops, you can save far more if you discover this suit carrier online. There are tons with internet shopping sites marketing garment plus louis vuitton rolling eole m93553 within lower prices to catch the attention of more buyers. Therefore, employ this opportunity to look for suit hand louis vuitton rolling eole m93553 in deal prices.Louis Vuitton Outlet Online This really is another practical buying avenue to discover affordable louis vuitton coming eole m93553 for agrees with. Visit reputable auction web sites, such as Ebay and also Amazon, to discover louis vuitton rolling eole m93553 that are currently upward for maximum taker. Make sure to make a good bidding price in case however, you find a louis vuitton coming eole m93553 style that will interests you. Keep in mind buyer work by getting the most beneficial and most sensible rates for bids through interested customers.
Bids generally start really low so you will surely be able to get a reasonable price for this auctioned suit garment carrier.
Great! I like your point of view…
This blog is really interesting good one thanks
This FM TRANSMITTER has been designed to fit and compliment the design of the iPhone, iPod Touch and any iPod with a dock connector (iPod Video, Classic, Mini, Photo, Colour etc). Unlike many other iPod FM transmitters, this one has a sleek and slim line design (see images below) and the sound quality is superb. It has the brilliant feature of being powered by your iPod (and only uses a small amount of power) so you don’t need to take extra chargers with you. Also, even though it plugs into the bottom of your iPhone or iPod, you can still charge your music player as this FM transmitter has a charge socket underneath it too. If possible you should try to stay away from the FM TRANSMITTER that also function as a cell phone mount. The reason is that while driving the car’s vibration gets transferred to the mobile and the connector between the fm transmitter and the mobile keeps on breaking up. Once the connect has broken connection the iPhone or iPod will stop playing until you click on it to play again.
Hi Uncle Bob,
I find it hilarious in how you week after week, I set aside 30 minutes or so every day to practice, and practice, and practice—just the way I used to practice my Jiu Jitsu Katas.
Comparing coding and martial arts is something that I’ve never come across. Coding performance? I’ve never heard of it, even in 2011 and I work in a web development company.
I hope you’ve improved significantly since this article was posted.
I really want to thank yahoo search engine who have sent me to this wonderful site. The articles posted on this site are great and amazing. I am glad that I have found this amazing sit. Internet Complaints
I think knitting is not a bad idea. Actually its a form of business that anyone can benefit from. Senior Marketing Allen TX
Thanks for sharing valuable information and i hope it will work beneficial on the same…chinese language immersion
mac cosmetics oakley active sunglasses wholesale mac cosmetics Oakley Sport Sunglasses mac lipstick Yanggengsheng
mac cosmetics oakley active sunglasses wholesale mac cosmetics Oakley Sport Sunglasses mac lipstick Yanggengsheng
http://www.baolai-machinery.com/search/0/concrete pipe making machine,cement pipe making,drain pipe making machine,concrete drain pipe making machine.html
http://www.chinaled6.com/html_products/LED-underwater-pond-light-117.html
http://www.chinaled6.com/html_products/LED-underwater-pond-light-117.html
http://www.rhinks.com/products_info/L-44-18Y0144—156244.html
Nice article. The katas is important software but it doesn’t spread.
it is necessary to have a backup of the text message from your phone.
This thought might not have occurred to you before; but it’s self-evidently true. Professional musicians practice. Professional dancers practice. Doctors practice. Soldiers practice. Indeed, any kind of professional craftsman or artisan must practice their adopted trade in order to execute it well when it counts.
Most of the users confirm that the remanufactured ink and toner cartridges perform equally well, if not better than the brand new ones. This improved performance of the remanufactured cartridges is mainly contributed to the fact that most of the reputed remanufacturing companies exercise great quality control measures
I always learn something new when I come to this blog, enjoy the photos and videos too, but I never have said thanks. So let me take the time now to say thank you and i’m going to finish reading through
Looking forward to learn some more from you. Keep it up.
Really appreciable post i was searching for such post keep going. :)
ements that you must bother about once you invest in possession. Fees, blog titles, payment repayment and various outdoor affects can offer Property Lawyer an awesome effect on a person in any other case taken care of correctly. Most significant difficulties is actually prestigious website.
That Arizona prestigious website legislations is actually challenging to be able to steer only therefore it is best you do have a residence lawyer to support show you. Situations regarding prestigious website impact an average completely ” up ” big businesses. The truth is, that Dallas Cowboys came across an exceptionally time-consuming prestigious website circumstance previous to put on construct its fresh arena.
I believe information is what makes the world go around. Without it, we would wander around aimlessly without direction. Your content is a great informational piece with very valid points.
Magnificent post, very informative! Will definitely be simply subscribing to the feed .un dijeta
This is my very first time I visited here. I discovered numerous cool stuff in your website especially its discussion. From the tons of feedback in your articles, I suppose I am not the one getting all of the enjoyment right here! Proceed the excellent job.
It is nonsense? we should think about it twice.
I appreciate this post.Thanks
I’m very glad I found your weblog on stumble upon. Thanks for the sensible critique. I and my girlfriend were just preparing to do a little analysis about this. I’m very glad to see such good information being shared freely out there.
This is my very first time I visited here. I discovered numerous cool stuff in your website especially its discussion. From the tons of feedback in your articles, I suppose I am not the one getting all of the enjoyment right here! Proceed the excellent job.
Martin is one of Sydney’s leading suburban law firms.We have the best lawyers Sydney and lawyers Melbourne or Melbourne lawyers . Our service includes property lawyer , Divorce Lawyer sydney ,timber flooring sydney and family law expert,etc ts is long term and we pride ourselves on our ability to provide quick analysis and evaluation, and resolution of your legal problems.
Thanks for sharing valuable information
It is great post .I like it
You are so talented in writing. God is really using you in tremendous methods. You are doing a great job! This was a wonderful article.!thank you
yes
Many people enjoy cheap Gucci belts for themselves. Even other popular leather belts such as cheap Hermes belts are on sale now.
I am not sure where this buzz was, but this is the first time I have heard of katas and the post is over 2 years old. I have always used the keyboard more often than the mouse, so it is good see more people doing this.
Gangaurrealtech use his skills, energy and creative spirits to bring novelty into real estate and other social assets.
http://www.allwindturbine.com/products_info/H2-7-500w-wind-generator-for-home-129702.html
H2.7-500w wind generator for homehttp://www.allwindturbine.com/products_info/Wind-Solar-Hybrid-System-wind-generator-128575.html
Wind-Solar Hybrid System wind generatorhttp://www.allwindturbine.com/products_info/windmill-126715.html
windmillhttp://www.allwindturbine.com/products_info/wind-turbine-generator-128880.html
wind turbine generatorhttp://www.allwindturbine.com/products_info/wind-turbine-generator-128886.html
wind turbine generatorhttp://www.allwindturbine.com/products_info/wind-solar-hybrid-system-wind-generator-128910.html
wind-solar hybrid system wind generatorhttp://www.allwindturbine.com/products_info/wind-solar-hybrid-system-wind-generator-128910.html
wind-solar hybrid system wind generatorThanks for sharing such a useful information, will be checking out more from yours.
Thanks for the information, I’ll visit the site again to get update information online shopping
I always learn something new when I come to this blog, enjoy the photos and videos too, but I never have said thanks. pdf editor for mac, edit pdf on mac os
I have been looking for content like this to get a research project I are working. Thanks very considerably.
nice post
http://myboatplans.net http://photosofistanbul.com thank you
I just like the approach you took with this subject.
Intertech Machinery Inc. provides the most precise Plastic Injection Mold and Rubber Molds from Taiwan. With applying excellent unscrewing device in molds,
Intertech is also very professional for making flip top Cap Molds in the world. Mold making is the core business of Intertech (Taiwan). With world level technology, Intertech enjoys a very good reputation for making Injection Mold and Plastic Molds for their worldwide customers.
Intertech Machinery Inc. provides the most precise Plastic Injection Mold and Rubber Molds from Taiwan. With applying excellent unscrewing device in molds,
Intertech is also very professional for making flip top Cap Molds in the world. Mold making is the core business of Intertech (Taiwan). With world level technology, Intertech enjoys a very good reputation for making Injection Mold and Plastic Molds for their worldwide customers.
Chopard sunglasses had all glamorous elements with metal chain arm,Tom Ford Eyeglasses heart strass and diamente.Loewe don signature anagrams arranged along the temple or fixed on the hinges for aviator and wide-eyed sunglasses.Tom Ford elegant oversized and gladiators came in various shades colours, contra tone thick frame or dual-toned temples.Tom For Sunglasses
With more than 20 years of experience, Intertech provides an extensive integrated operational ability from design to production of molds 100% made in Taiwan. Additional to our own mold making factory, we also cooperate with our team vendors to form a very strong working force in Taiwan.
For the overseas market, we work very closely with local representatives in order to take care of the technical communication and after-sales service to our customers. We also participate in the EUROMOLD & FAKUMA exhibitions and meet our customers every year in Europe. By concentrating on mold “niche markets”, we play a very useful mold maker role from the Far East whenever customers want to develop their new projects. We provide services from A to Z to our customers on a very economic cost and effect basis.
I am happy to find this post Very useful for me, as it contains lot of information. I Always prefer to read The Quality and glad I found this thing in you post. Thanks
You are so talented in writing. God is really using you in tremendous methods. You are doing a great job! This was a wonderful article.!thank you
Good things always make people so like, could not help but want to have it
Thank you for this great article. I have read it and it truly is very useful.
Thank you for this great article. I have read it and it truly is very useful.
It is very useful and informative blog post. I enjoyed reading it
It is very useful and informative blog post. I enjoyed reading it
I love reading your blog good. I can provide you with invaluable information. Fell intothis opportunity to blog, but I’m sure glad I clicked the link. You must answer all the questions I have been scrambling to answer for some time. Will come back to this moretrouble.
Intertech Machinery Inc.
With more than 25 years of experience, Intertech provides an extensive integrated operational ability from design to production of molds 100% made in Taiwan. Additional to our own mold making factory, we also cooperate with our team vendors to form a very strong working force in Taiwan.
Main Products:
Injection Mold, Silicone Molding, Rubber Mold, Silicone molding, PC High-Gloss Plastic Mold, Die Casting Mold, Silicone Mold, Silicone Rubber Mold, Liquid Silicone Rubber , Cosmetic Packaging Mold, Medical Products Mold, Engineering Plastic Molds, Home Appliances Mold, etc…